Matthew_90 2022-09-19

Review Time: 6.5 weeks

The average number of weeks it takes for an article to go through the editorial review process for this journal, including standard and desk rejects.

It has been almost a month with the editor now, and I wonder if it really takes 6.5 weeks to determine whether it will proceed to external review or be rejected.

爱上做学术 2022-09-08

Definitely a tragedy, hehe.

Swink 2022-09-06

The initial review rate of journals is relatively strict, with a maximum repetition rate of 2% per article. Before submission, you can first check for duplication on Taobao. The review process takes around 4 to 5 months.

mathzl 2022-08-19

Posted in May 2020, accepted in June 2022, with one revision in between. It's been very slow.

杜杜早日毕业 2022-08-15

Original: 楼主，请问当时审稿人只有一个么？
Translation: Excuse me, poster, were there only one reviewer at that time?

杜杜早日毕业 2022-08-13

Original: 楼主，请问现在论文状态变了么？
Translation: OP, has the status of the paper changed now?

云深不知处 2022-08-08

2022-08-01 submitted
2022-08-02 with editor

爱学习的东东 2022-08-02

Original: 楼主，with editor已经2月了，还没信，怎么破催稿信没回应。

Translation: OP, it has been two months with the editor, and still no response. How should I handle the situation when the reminder letter hasn't been answered?

RememberMon 2022-08-02

Posted on June 22, 2022, under review since June 27th. Currently still under review. Interestingly, during this period, I was invited by the AMC journal to review an article, with a review deadline of 45 days. Therefore, I have a rough idea of the first review cycle for this journal. This journal doesn't seem as easy as others have claimed. Firstly, the initial review requires strict plagiarism checks, and additionally, the journal also has certain requirements for the novelty of the article. Lastly, I hope my article will be accepted soon!

爱学习的东东 2022-07-27

"How can I withdraw the manuscript and resolve the situation when the status has been 'WITH EDITOR' for 2 months? They don't even respond to emails."

mystery01 2022-07-25

1. You can just search for Tmall on Taobao. I suggest you hang AirXiv before checking for plagiarism.
2. The first time was about plagiarism issue, and the second time it went directly to the review process. It provided a lot of useful information, and it felt like it was almost accepted. However, it was withdrawn due to personal reasons.

阿狸啊 2022-07-19

Classmate, may I ask you some questions?

阿狸啊 2022-07-19

Original: 楼主，可以请教您几个问题吗
Translation: Host, may I ask you a few questions?

阿狸啊 2022-07-19

Can the original poster ask you some questions about submitting contributions?

芝麻开门开门 2022-07-09

Hello, may I ask if the host is able to inform whether new reviewers were added for the second submission? How did it turn out in the end?

爱学习的东东 2022-07-06

Slow speed, With Editor hasn't responded for a whole month, don't know what to do.

小猫不吃鱼 2022-07-06

It has been four or five days since the required reviews were completed. Is this normal?

老天让我毕业吧 2022-06-18

2022.4.14 submitted
2022.4.19 under review
2022.6.2 revise
2022.6.6 revision submitted
2022.6.18 accept
So fast! Graduation masterpiece, highly praised!

GuoCY 2022-06-02

You are very fast! I want to ask if I, as the first author, can receive these reply emails or check the status of my paper as it was submitted by my supervisor?

不做舔狗 2022-05-31

So disgusting, no need to check, checking is just with the editor. If you don't have time to read submissions, then don't be an editor!

微微微 2022-05-30

Did you send the email? Did I send it and not receive a reply?

漫漫科研虫 2022-05-23

I have been with the editor for over a month, and it still hasn't been submitted for review. It's too slow.

dalala123 2022-05-10

2021.10.12 Submission
2022. 2. 8 Return with revision suggestions
2022. 3. 7 Submit revised manuscript
2022. 5. 6 Accepted
Three reviewers provided very professional comments. The revision period was only one month, and time was tight. It is a very good journal, not easy to get accepted.

QQ飞车转战LOL 2022-04-28

Sorry, the speed of reviewing should be 12 months. I thought you were asking how long it takes on average to reply to an email. My mistake.

QQ飞车转战LOL 2022-04-28

202105 submitted, 202204 published online.
Revised twice in the process.
The reviewer was very serious and meticulous.
They also provided many good suggestions.
After two revisions, it was quickly accepted for publication.
Feeling quite happy about it.
Hope everyone goes smoothly and happily.

xiaohen 2022-04-27

Can the original poster recommend a Taobao store?

mystery01 2022-04-22

April 8, 2022 - Submitted
April 9, 2022 - With Editor
April 10, 2022 - Rejected due to a single document similarity exceeding 2%. Conducted searches and made multiple modifications using iThenrucate and Turnitin libraries on Taobao.
April 18, 2022 - Resubmitted
April 19, 2022 - With Editor
April 20, 2022 - Under Review
April 23, 2022 - Decision in process. Only three days and they already gave me a result? I thought there was no external review.
April 24, 2022 - Revision. There are actually reviewer comments, this efficiency is too fast. One reviewer has already replied, expressing interest but requiring grammar and citation revisions.

jjonas 2022-04-08

Because the editing efficiency is too low and I want to withdraw the submission, I sent an email but no one responded. It just hangs there, and I will not submit again in the future.

小艹溜溜 2022-04-07

It has been almost a month with the editor...

jjonas 2022-04-04

It has been nearly a month, and there has been no response to the email from the editor, which is concerning given the lack of efficiency.