雪诺 2021-11-17

My one-month leave is back now. I applied on August 3rd and got approved in November.

麦迪阿拉卡 2021-11-17

Very good, it lasted for nearly one and a half months, and finally went through the second review. It's really great. It took almost four months in total, including the first review, revision, and the second review.

xiao e 2021-11-16

How long do you decide to be?

追光er 2021-11-13

November 12th, accept

tushan0821 2021-11-08

Definitely, this word should be used with caution.

追光er 2021-11-08

The submission cycle is relatively long, but the journal has good influence and the impact factor has been increasing. It is a promising journal.
submit 7.26
major revision 8.24
submit R1 9.16
minor revision 10.19
submit R2 10.26
with editor 10.26-11.08 (No results have been given yet)

麦迪阿拉卡 2021-11-08

It should be an editor. I surrender directly.

pkw 2021-11-06

Some editors of this publication are extremely irresponsible. Even after a month of submission, it is still "with editor". Despite multiple emails urging a response from the editor, there was only a generic reply from Elsevier staff. Helplessly, I had to withdraw my submission on my own.

Klaatu 2021-11-04

7/30/2021, submitted to journal
7/31/2021, with editor
8/1/2021, under review
11/2/2021, required review completed
11/3/2021, Decision in Process

It has been over three months since the review process started, and the results are still not out. It's really slow.

If it gets rejected, it will be very disheartening.

buaa刘炳森 2021-10-29

The duration of the first round is relatively short, about 10 days, while the duration after repair is relatively long, about 25 days.

summermelody 2021-10-29

Received 25 May 2021
Received in revised form 13 September 2021
Resubmitted on 13 October 2021
Accepted on 25 October 2021
Two reviewers provided major revisions, and coincidentally, I went on vacation, so it took me a month to submit the revised version.
The comments were quite professional, and the editor was nice, but the speed was average. Overall, it felt okay.
After submitting the revisions, I coincidentally had my handling editor promoted to the editor-in-chief, so there was a slight delay due to the change.

倔强的奥斯特 2021-10-27

Laser processing direction was submitted for 50 days and was rejected, which really hurts.
There were 5 reviewers, 1 accepted directly, 1 minor revision, 1 revision, 1 with a negative bias, and 1 rejection. The editor directly rejected it.
The reason for rejection is also weak, I wanted to argue a bit, but after looking at dozens of questions, it's better to resubmit with two reviewers from district 2.

frank小北 2021-10-27

I have been with the editor for almost two months and I still don't know what's going on. I don't know if I should remind them about the manuscript.

东北彭于晏 2021-10-25

The submission cycle is four months long, and I made a wrong choice.

东北彭于晏 2021-10-25

jun. 22, 2021, submitted to journal
jul. 23, 2021, with editor
jul. 07, 2021, under review
jul. 14, 2021, major revision
jul. 28,2021, submitted to journal
jul. 29, 2021, with editor
aug. 13, 2021, under review
sep. 1, 2021, minor revisions
sep. 3, 2021, with editor
oct. 5, 2021 under review
oct. 20, 2021, accept

Translated:
jun. 22, 2021, submitted to journal
jul. 23, 2021, with editor
jul. 07, 2021, under review
jul. 14, 2021, major revision
jul. 28,2021, submitted to journal
jul. 29, 2021, with editor
aug. 13, 2021, under review
sep. 1, 2021, minor revisions
sep. 3, 2021, with editor
oct. 5, 2021 under review
oct. 20, 2021, accept

optics 皮卡丘 2021-10-22

Why do you think IF will definitely exceed 4?

lesserpandia 2021-10-22

May I ask how long your "required reviews completed" status has been lasting? I have been waiting for over 20 days, and this status hasn't changed at all.

buaa刘炳森 2021-10-22

7,15, 2021, submitted to journal
7,22, 2021, with editor
7,30, 2021, under review
8,24, 2021, major revision
9,06, 2021, submitted to journal
9,16, 2021, with editor
9,26, 2021, under review
9,30, 2021, required review completed
10,15, 2021, accept

The editor and reviewers were quite fast, and I appreciate Professor Marc Sentis for his prompt handling of the manuscript. Both reviewers were professional and their suggestions greatly improved the article. One of the reviewers requested additional experiments, but since the reasons for not conducting them were explained, the reviewer still gave a positive response.

光学倒霉蛋 2021-10-20

Ask everyone a question, does the OLT need to confirm the co-author's email before accepting the submission? Will it affect the final acceptance? It doesn't matter if you don't pay attention to it (although it will still be reviewed without confirmation).

山芋派 2021-10-19

Be patient, my second review is also almost like this. This editing process is indeed slow~

yinghan 2021-10-19

OKOK, understood. My second revised manuscript has been with the editor for over a month now and it hasn't been under review yet. I've been anxiously waiting! A couple of days ago, I received an email for co-author confirmation. I'm not sure what's going on. Thanks to my friends for their answers~~~ Congratulations on having another SCI paper!! That's impressive!! I'm also basking in the good vibes.

yinghan 2021-10-19

How many times have you received confirmation emails from co-authors?

yinghan 2021-10-19

How many times have you received the co-author confirmation email in total?

灵儿 2021-10-19

It has been almost a year since the manuscript submission, and there is still no news. I have sent two reminder letters, but everyone else seems to be getting accepted quickly. My graduation is being delayed because of this paper, and I don't know when it will be returned. I hope it can be expedited.

山芋派 2021-10-19

Overall, the reviewers reviewed the manuscript quickly, but the editor was really slow. Each step of the process took a long time.

yinghan 2021-10-18

The situation I encountered is: After submitting, I would receive a confirmation email immediately, and even without clicking, it would still be reviewed.

NWPU007 2021-10-18

Do all authors need to confirm before this journal is submitted for review? The system has automatically sent an email to the co-authors, is it necessary to click on the confirmation?

哇咔咔2 2021-10-17

On October 17th, the real-time IF is 3.617. The new partition released at the end of the year, whether it is the standard version or the upgraded version, will definitely enter Zone 2. It is a good deal to invest now, as the current released issues are all for 2022. Barring any unexpected circumstances, the new factor shadow released next year may exceed 4, definitely surpassing OE and OL.

yinghan 2021-10-15

May I ask when will this journal send an email to the co-authors to confirm their collaboration? It has been a month since the second revision with the editor, and recently all the co-authors have received emails.

yinghan 2021-10-15

May I ask when will this journal send an email to confirm the co-authors? It has been a month since the second revision with the editor. On the 13th, I received an email regarding the confirmation of co-authors, which seems to have given me hope.