stellar 2022-06-20

After 8 months of experience, I finally received it and can now share the process of submitting the manuscript from the perspective of someone who has been through it.
October 19, 2021: Submission
November 3, 2021: Under review
February 6, 2022: Major revisions requested, with 2 reviewers providing 30 comments
March 26, 2022: Revised manuscript resubmitted
May 20, 2022: Minor revisions
May 22, 2022: Revised manuscript resubmitted
June 20, 2022: Accepted
I chose Thomas Glade for submission, and the chief editor during the major revision process was Harsh Gupta, who is very serious and strict. I am grateful to the chief editor for giving me this opportunity!

melody 2022-06-20

How long will it take to receive the proof?

melody 2022-06-20

Excuse me, has the manuscript been proofread? I haven't received any news for a month.

melody 2022-06-20

Hello, have you received the proff? It has been over a month since I accepted it, but I haven't received any updates.

一定要中啊啊啊 2022-06-18

The speed is too slow. Submitted on 2021.10.15.
Since 2022.3.8, it changed from "with editor" to "under review", and has been reminded three times in between. It has been eight months and there is still no response to the first-round comments.

杜青木 2022-06-13

2022.06.07 editor assigned
2022.07.25 reviewers assigned
2022.07.26 under review
2022.09.02 reviewers assigned Only one reviewer provided feedback, seven more reviewers needed
2023.01.10 reviewers assigned (sent email to editor, received official reply, editor did not respond) Sending monthly reminder emails, feeling exhausted.

tzz 2022-05-17

Oh my goodness!

Submitted on July 7, 2021.
I can't remember the exact duration of the under review process, but it lasted for a while.
On September 30, 2021, it changed to "Reviewers Assigned".
On November 23, 2021, I sent an email inquiring about the situation and was informed that someone had rejected the review. I was asked to provide another 5 reviewers, which I promptly did.
It wasn't until May 15, 2022, that it finally became "Reviews Completed".

During these 7 months, I sent a total of 5 or 6 emails. Apart from the time I was asked to provide reviewers, all the responses were very official. The last email I sent didn't even receive a reply.

Sigh, it's been 10 months and I still haven't received the result of the first review. I don't know what the final outcome will be. It's just too slow. I won't submit again in the future.

你好123 2022-05-07

The journal has a decent reputation and belongs to the upper-mid range within the field of earth sciences.

抗压的上单 2022-04-22

Have you proofread it now?

AaronHW 2022-03-22

The quality of the reviewers for this journal is very poor. I am working on the field of geophysics, but I found reviewers who specialize in water resources. They provided a bunch of completely irrelevant reviewers and gave a lot of comments that have nothing to do with the paper. The reason is that my research has offended the academic interests of certain individuals.

jiandanjiandan 2022-03-16

2021.10.1 Submission
2021.11.26 Under Review
2022.02.08 Major Revision
2022.02.25 Revised
2022.03.08 Accepted
Edited by Thomas Glade

棠梨 2022-03-10

Already hired, update the timeline:
August 3, 2021 - Submitted
October 25, 2021 - Major revision
December 1, 2021 - Resubmitted after major revision
January 28, 2022 - Minor revision
January 30, 2022 - Resubmitted after minor revision
March 8, 2022 - Accepted
First SCI article, wishing the journal continued success!

肥肥是不是 2022-03-08

May I ask if you have received the information about the proofreading manuscript? How long did it take for you to receive the final decision of acceptance?

肥肥是不是 2022-03-08

It has been almost a month since the final decision was accepted, but I have not received the proof yet. I wonder if others who have already accepted it have encountered the same situation?

棠梨 2022-03-06

The major revision took 2 months, and then I made minor revisions and returned two days later. After that, it took another month for the review, and now there are still no results. Waiting is so agonizing. Does this journal always take so long for minor revisions?

baoyd20 2022-02-15

Highly efficient journal

ZZH 2021-10-25

Hello, may I ask if your thesis is open for external review?

Stefan 2021-10-24

First instance
Passed directly
Thank you LetPut English editing
Jyh-Woei Lin

rockU 2021-10-14

It has been a month already, still "Editor Assigned," and it has not been reviewed yet.

Ethaaaaaaaan 2021-09-19

The speed is so slow, I don't know what the three editors are doing. It has been a year since I submitted, and it is still under review.

DrunkTotoro 2021-09-08

What happened later? Now I am also a reviewer assigned. I have never seen this kind of status before when I submitted to other journals!

小水滴k 2021-08-18

How long does it usually take for the first review comments to come out for this journal? It has been under review continuously.

柚子123 2021-07-27

Submission in March, major revision in June, minor revision in early July (to modify the language), took half a month to make changes and returned, accepted in four days.

XinYeaug 2021-07-21

The quality of the journal is very good, with a good reputation and a nice name. However, the review process is very slow. I submitted my article in December last year and it went under review, but then it was reassigned to another reviewer. The assistant editor asked for a new reviewer. At the beginning of the month, I sent a reminder email and received a response saying that the article lacked innovation. It took a whole seven months to receive a review. The speed is a bit slow. The editor-in-chief is an expert from India.

BosTon 2021-07-07

Original text: 楼主，Editor assigned 到下一步需要多久啊？editor assigned 一个月之后又变成了editor invited

Translation: OP, how long does it take for Editor assigned to move on to the next step? After one month, Editor assigned changed to Editor invited.

Superman 2021-07-05

It has been under review for 4 months, but there is no result at all.

从此只发top文章 2021-04-15

Reviewed for two years and called it "quick"? You really are a first-time contributor.

从此只发top文章 2021-04-15

Hello, can you please let me know which editor you have chosen?

JLU-White 2021-02-09

Translated text:

Received: 04 Oct 2020
Under Review: 07 Oct 2020
Minor Revision: 21 Dec 2020
Accept: 24 Dec 2020

Superman 2021-01-25

Dude, when did you submit your manuscript? Has it been assigned to an editor this whole time?