认证评论 - MEASUREMENT SCIENCE and TECHNOLOGY
Alyssa1997 2023-05-04
I need to obtain academic achievements before May 24th when I graduate. Ahhh, I'm so anxious. Bless me, Fusheng Wuliang Tianzun, Bodhisattva, please help me, wuwuwu, save me, please. I beg all the reviewers to be lenient, and editors to have mercy on me, wuwuwu, it's really not easy, I'm crying.
菜菜老大 2023-05-03
Can I say that this might be a disaster?
WayneCopper 2023-05-03
4.18 Submission
5.3 Still under review or editing
god...........
sdf457889 2023-05-02
5.2 The first reviewer starts reviewing.
菜菜老大 2023-04-30
Are you this fast?
横山一俊 2023-04-30
Hello, I would like to ask about the fee situation for this journal. I did not choose OA.
横山一俊 2023-04-30
4.18 Submission
4.20 The first reviewer agrees to review
5.5 Received reviewer's comments, the editorial office seems to make a decision (but there is only one reviewer), should send it to another reviewer
5.9 Review of the manuscript, They recommend that you make some revisions before further consideration by Measurement Science and Technology. Both reviewers have five comments, some of which are simple and some are difficult. Deadline for revision is 5.23. Wish me luck.
5.20 Revision
5.25 Submit copyright form
6.9 Continue editing, Reviewer 1 agrees, Reviewer 25 comments
6.19 Revision
6.22 We are pleased to tell you that we are provisionally accepting your Paper
6.29 for what inclusion, you can see on the official website the accepted manuscript.
sdf457889 2023-04-27
4.21 Under review, waiting.
5.2 The first reviewer begins reviewing.
XATU东东 2023-04-26
I see that the 139th comment mentions that the review speed is relatively fast.
XATU东东 2023-04-26
My two months, it was said that an expert agreed to review, and the report has been received. Still looking for another expert, there has been no progress.
TomStark 2023-04-26
Submitted on February 17th, it has been almost three months now and the status is still "awaiting referee reports". It's too slow.
coolla 2023-04-22
Hello! Do you need to revise the mode or is it enough to annotate with different colors?
硕果 2023-04-22
4.14 manuscript received, one week has passed, status unchanged.
4.25 sent for review after two weeks.
6.7 major revision after a month and a half, quite fast, unexpected.
sdf457889 2023-04-20
It has been half a month, and it still hasn't been reviewed. Trembling with fear.
一斤菌 2023-04-15
Updating status...
2023.03.21 Major revision, given one month's time, two reviewers, a total of 40 comments. Most of the comments are very pertinent, and there are also some professional suggestions. The two experts have different emphases, but both contribute to the improvement of the article's quality. Feeling that it is still a good journal in the field of measurement.
2023.04.14 Revised and sent back, waiting for the next miracle...
XATU东东 2023-04-14
Rejoicing with good luck, 3.3 has been delivered, it has been over a month now.
XATU东东 2023-04-14
3.3投递的,同坐等。 translates to "Delivered on 3.3, wait together."
sdf457889 2023-04-13
4.7 Manuscript Received
黄焖鸡煎蛋 2023-04-11
04-Dec-2022 submitted manuscript
23-Feb-2023 major revision (Two reviewers carefully reviewed the manuscript and provided excellent suggestions on both grammar and fundamental theory. Based on their recommendations, a large number of experiments and applications were added, highlighting the innovation and data comparison.)
22-Mar-2023 submitted revision
6-Apr-2023 provisionally accepted and copyright completion (The copyright was emailed to the corresponding author on 30-Mar-2023, but was not seen and submitted late.)
11-Apr-2023 Formal Accept
Alyssa1997 2023-04-05
Thank you for sharing, I would like to ask two questions. I wonder if you could answer them, thank you.
1. When it says "provide an anonymous PDF of the revised manuscript with tracked changes" for revising the reply, does it mean that the revised draft should be in Word's track changes mode? Because I want to use different font colors to modify sections based on different reviewers' comments, I'm not sure if I can directly make modifications.
2. The line numbers in my document do not match the line numbers generated by the system for the PDF. How can I specify the line numbers when indicating the modification locations in the response? Can I upload the revised draft to obtain the line numbers and then modify the content in the response?
putong0708 2023-04-05
The review process is relatively fast. The submission was made on December 30, 2022, and feedback for major revisions was received in early February. The review comments were relatively mild, but there were quite a few of them. They helped point out grammar, spelling, and other errors. In early March, further feedback was provided for minor revisions, and in early April, the paper was accepted directly.
alanzhai 2023-04-02
After being provisionally accepted, will the copyright transfer reminder email be sent to the corresponding author or to all authors?
东川大尾巴 2023-03-29
30-Mar-2023 Awaiting Referee Reports
Translation: We are currently waiting for the reports from the referees.
XATU东东 2023-03-28
I also submitted my manuscript on March 3rd, and I am currently the first reviewer who agreed to review it. I have received the reviewer's report.
XATU东东 2023-03-28
I submitted it on March 3rd, it's been almost a month now. The current status is that one reviewer has agreed to review it and I have received the reviewer's report.
XATU东东 2023-03-28
Basking in good fortune, the submission made on March 3rd currently only has one reviewer.
东川大尾巴 2023-03-27
When can the editing review be completed?
ICer2023 2023-03-27
The journal editor is very responsible, but the speed of the reviewers they encountered is slow. Fortunately, the results are good, but the speed of the review process feels like a matter of luck.
Walker621 2023-03-27
Has the editor reviewed it?
Walker621 2023-03-27
Is the review speed fast?
Become a Peeref-certified reviewer
The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.
Get Started