唐人 2022-05-09

2022.05.08 is under review.

Lulu 2022-05-08

May I ask how to interpret the reviewers' comments as "major revision," "minor revision," or "acceptance"? I cannot find such information in the reviewers' comments.

Lulu 2022-05-08

2022.2.21: With editor
2022.3.06: Under review
2022.3.28: Required reviews completed
2022.4.13: Submission
2022.4.16: With editor
2022.4.25: Under review
2022.5.06: Required reviews completed
Waiting for results

飞翔的单帅杰 2022-05-05

Record the following:

Mar 27, 2022 submitted;
Mar 29, 2022 With Editor;
May 04, 2022 Under Review.

lovage 2022-05-05

April 18, 2022, I am still in the process of revising~

摸鱼选手 2022-05-05

No page limit. My field is civil engineering and rock and soil mechanics. The results should also be included. Overall, the submission is suggested, and the review process is relatively fast.

Mchen 2022-05-05

Did you reply now? It has been under review for a long time.

Mchen 2022-05-05

Did you remind them and receive a response? I'm worried that if I remind them, they will reject me directly. It has been almost 5 months since my application is under review, but I haven't dared to remind them.

Mchen 2022-05-05

Is there a result now?

Mchen 2022-05-05

My application has also been under review for several months. During this period, the dates have changed several times, but until now, there has been no outcome. Have you received any results for yours?

唐人 2022-05-04

There is no specific mention of the actual repetition rate, but generally speaking, after checking for plagiarism, an overall repetition rate of no more than 20% and a maximum single-page repetition rate of 3% are considered relatively safe. After my final modifications, the overall repetition rate is 17%, and the maximum single-page repetition rate is 1%.

DEPENGSUN 2022-05-04

4.4投的，现在5.4 一个月了还是在with editor

I submitted it on April 4th, and now it's May 4th. It has been a month, and it is still with the editor.

swjtu_lxr 2022-05-03

May I ask what is your repetition rate?

C49115487 2022-05-02

2021-11-29 Submission
2022-01-06 First review
2022-03-20 First review ended with reject and resubmit
2022-03-27 Resubmit
2022-04-08 Under review
2022-04-22 Second review ended with reject and resubmit
2022-04-27 Resubmit
2022-05-02 Reject

During the second review, there was one acceptance, one rejection, and one minor revision, but it still resulted in reject and resubmit. The reviewer was not someone I recommended.

After the final round of resubmission, the editor said they still felt that there was no innovation and decided to reject it.

Overall, the review process was fast, but due to the short time, the reviewers didn't pay close attention to many things. The editor was very harsh.

唐人 2022-05-02

2022.03.30 Submitted initial draft
2022.03.31 With editor
2022.04.03 Rejection and resubmission (high similarity rate) (due to my own negligence, I forgot to check for plagiarism before submitting)
2022.04.08 Submitted manuscript
2022.04.10 With editor
2022.04.14 Under review
2022.04.29 Under review
I hope the next review will have a positive outcome.

XNL2013 2022-05-01

Hello, OP, is there a word limit for this journal? I noticed that most of the published articles are around ten to twelve pages after the formatting.

Annia 2022-05-01

Hello, I am an expert in structural reliability and also in civil engineering. I would like to contribute to this magazine. Could you please provide some advice?

摸鱼选手 2022-04-29

Submitted on 2022.1.23, under review on 1.25, under review on 1.30, under review on 2.2, under review on 2.25. "Under review" changed three times. On 3.2, major revisions were requested. Reviewer 1 rejected the manuscript completely. Reviewer 2 had several minor issues. Reviewer 3 accepted it directly. Reviewer 4 had five minor issues.

Resubmitted on 3.14 for revisions. On 4.8, another major revision was requested. It seems that the editor found Reviewer 1 unreliable and deleted their comments. Reviewer 2 had two more minor issues. Reviewer 3 accepted it directly. Reviewer 4 insisted on citing their own paper, a terrible Indian person. Their paper and my topic are not related at all.

Resubmitted again on 4.12, reviewed by an external reviewer on 4.14. Received acceptance notification on 4.29.

However, a fifth reviewer was added. Fortunately, their comments were more positive. The acceptance notification mentioned one additional issue from Reviewer 2 and four minor issues from Reviewer 5. But it was still accepted directly.

I am grateful to the editor for giving me this opportunity. Reviewer 1 was very irresponsible, just criticizing for the sake of it. This is my second SCI paper in my second year of graduate school. And I received the notification while playing mahjong, hahaha.

菜鸡就是me 2022-04-29

How to view several reviewers?

叔均 2022-04-29

I changed the date a month later, it should be a review comment returned. Is this considered fast or slow?

叔均 2022-04-29

2022.4.6 submission,
4.7 with editor, two reviewers
4.9 under review,
4.26 receive a reviewer's comment
The progress is currently quite fast, hoping for acceptance.

史roc 2022-04-26

It should be a description of the external audit opinions being returned.

zzy_zzy123 2022-04-25

You're still slow. I submitted it on March 13th, and it took forty days to change from "with editor" to "under review." This journal has become much slower compared to before.

菜鸡就是me 2022-04-22

What does it mean when the date changes after two weeks under review?

YUANYUAN1231 2022-04-22

Please have an editor review this. I submitted it on the 28th, and it was reviewed three days later.

飞翔的单帅杰 2022-04-22

Submitted on March 27th, With Editor on March 29th, it has been three weeks today and it is still With Editor. Can I ask you experts if this situation is normal?

TOPpaper_Maker 2022-04-19

May I ask if the paper of the expert has been indexed now? If it has been indexed, how long does it usually take to be indexed after acceptance?

TOPpaper_Maker 2022-04-19

Excuse me, have you searched now? If you have searched, may I ask how long it usually takes to search after being hired?

史roc 2022-04-19

No fixed template is needed. Just use Word.

什么什么是什么辣 2022-04-19

May I ask, do you have a Word template or do I have to use a LaTeX template?