shengaoyimiba 2022-05-19

4.27 with editor, until now, should we remind and urge?

湘亚 2022-05-19

2022.01.08 Submit initial draft
2022.01.10 Under review
2022.02.14 Rejection and resubmission, 7 reviewers, 2 minor revisions, 2 major revisions, 1 rejection
2022.03.17 Submit initial draft
2022.04.10 Major revision, additional 2 reviewers
2022.04.20 Revisions requested
2022.05.02 Major revision, 1 reviewer accepted, 1 reviewer suggested detailed explanation for certain parameters
2022.05.03 Revisions requested
2022.05.10 Under review
2022.05.18 Accepted

唐人 2022-05-19

2022.5.18 under review translates to "Under review on May 18, 2022."

YUANYUAN1231 2022-05-18

May I ask if your date keeps changing as well? My date has already changed 5 times. It changes approximately every 8-12 days. It's difficult to determine whether it's a rejection or a request for further comments.

唐人 2022-05-18

Currently, it is still under review, and the plagiarism check is done using the ithenticate software adopted by the journal.

wyf233 2022-05-17

I have already sent two reminders, but it is still under review. Now it is just waiting as a sunk cost. I am seeking a solution.

lovage 2022-05-17

Finally, the revised draft was returned on May 17th. It was not easy, hopefully there will be a good outcome!!!

gzf 2022-05-17

Hello, I would like to ask if there is a PDF of the acceptance notice for the paper submission? My paper has been accepted, but I have not received such acceptance proof. Thank you.

Lulu 2022-05-17

Revised date: 2022.5.17 Accept with Minor Revision

Lulu 2022-05-17

Supplement: 2022.5.7 Accept with Minor Revision

YUANYUAN1231 2022-05-17

How do you determine if it is a feedback? Is it based on the date change? However, the date change could also be due to rejection or other reasons.

叔均 2022-05-17

2022.4.6 Submission
4.7 with edither, two reviewers
4.9 Under review
4.26 Receive one comment
5.2 Receive two comments
5.5 Rejected, Reviewer 1 mentioned lack of innovation, Reviewer 2 suggested minor revisions
5.15 Resubmission
5.17 Submitted to journal
Not sure if resubmission will be accepted.

我是一个小学生i 2022-05-17

5.17 is still with the editor.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-05-17

@Yahoo Fly, actually I'm not sure either. One reason is that I am an optical detector, and this journal is relatively niche, so many reviewers refuse to review it, causing the dates to change. Alternatively, if there are already review comments returned, the time may change. However, someone told me that nowadays most return of review comments and acceptance of reviews do not change the time, so it's likely that mine are all rejections.

雅虎飞 2022-05-17

What does the continuous change in the state during the review process mean?

独木舟* 2022-05-16

And the manuscript number grid is empty. I don't know if it's normal~

a斗 2022-05-15

My submission to the journal has also been four to five days, and there is still no update on the information.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-05-15

It may take up to a month for the manuscript to be reviewed, and during the review process, the dates may keep changing. However, there have been no results for several months.

我是一个小学生i 2022-05-14

5.4 submission
5.8 with editor until now
Possibly slower recently?

shengaoyimiba 2022-05-13

It has been almost 20 days, and still with the editor...

shengaoyimiba 2022-05-13

Please share the status of the submission on 4.26, the discussion with the editor on 4.27, and what is the current situation?

独木舟* 2022-05-13

Hello, I submitted my work on 5.10, but it is still being submitted to the journal today, 5.13... I don't know what's going on. Also, what software did you use to check for plagiarism?

Annia 2022-05-13

Thank you for the valuable suggestions, I have already submitted them. I hope for a good outcome.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-05-12

2022.3.28 Submission
2022.3.30 With editor
2022.4.03 Under Review
2022.4.12 Under Review
2022.4.24 Under Review
2022.5.04 Under Review
2022.5.12 Under Review
Waiting anxiously

YUANYUAN1231 2022-05-11

Do you have any news about the review now? I submitted it on March 28th, and from April 3rd until now, it has been under review. There has been no news so far, and I'm really afraid it will take several months for the first review.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-05-11

May I ask if you have any news about the review? I submitted it on March 28th, and from April 3rd until now, it has been under review. I haven't received any updates and I'm really afraid it will take months for the first review.

菜鸡就是me 2022-05-10

It has been a week since the required reviews were completed. Does this mean it will be rejected?

湘亚 2022-05-10

Recently, I don't know what's wrong, but I feel a bit slow, a kind of with editor.

RWZB 2022-05-09

I would like to ask if an associate editor will still be assigned after the first review and revision. It has been nearly 10 days since I submitted my revision, and it is still with the editor.

唐人 2022-05-09

2022.05.08 under review.