认证评论 - MEASUREMENT
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

xgdw 2022-06-30

Excuse me, how can I know which editor it is?

984130770 2022-06-29

This editor took 8 months to return the first-instance comments. I'm scared.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-06-28

Measurement, today the new impact factor of 5.1 has just been released. It will definitely be more difficult to submit in the future, as the number of submissions will increase.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-06-28

The translation of the text is: "Today, on 6.28, a new impact factor of 5.1 was just released. It will definitely be more difficult to submit in the future."

哎呀咿呀666 2022-06-28

My editor has also been with me for a month, but it's still a domestic editor. I don't know what's going on.

哎呀咿呀666 2022-06-28

It has been a month since I submitted it, and it has always been "with editor". Do you know what's going on, big shots?

哎呀咿呀666 2022-06-28

I have submitted for a month already, but it is still with the editor. Have you received any updates on yours?

xgdw 2022-06-28

May I ask how to know which editor is handling it?

独木舟* 2022-06-27

That is, until now, I haven't replied to the deadline you asked for, because I'm not very good at making changes to it. I'm afraid that if I don't submit it in time, it will be withdrawn. So I'm hesitant about whether or not to ask.

秋风暖暖 2022-06-26

This editor has always been nonsense. It's really unlucky to have encountered him...

YUANYUAN1231 2022-06-26

@独木舟* I didn't give any time. I asked the editor for a week but they didn't respond to me. However, after I submitted it, they sent it back to the reviewer. Let's calculate it as 21 days, which is usually the standard.

独木舟* 2022-06-25

May I ask if the landlord has given a deadline for the major repairs? I have requested major repairs, but I haven't seen any requirement to return for reparation by a specific date.

棒棒来冲浪 2022-06-25

2022 06 15 submit - Submitted on June 15, 2022
2022 06 17 with editor - Under review by the editor on June 17, 2022
2022 06 24 under review - Under review on June 24, 2022
2022 06 27 under review - Under review on June 27, 2022
2022 07 01 under review - Under review on July 1, 2022
2022 07 03 under review - Under review on July 3, 2022
2022 07 04 under review - Under review on July 4, 2022
2022 07 06 under review - Under review on July 6, 2022
2022 07 13 under review - Under review on July 13, 2022
2022 07 14 under review - Under review on July 14, 2022
2022 08 09 拒稿 (可以重投) - Rejected on August 9, 2022 (Can be resubmitted)
2022 12 20 Required Reviews Completed (大修重投后三个审稿人跑路了一个,又找新的审稿人,找了连个月时间,审稿人又审一个月,期刊太慢了) - Required reviews completed on December 20, 2022 (After major revisions and resubmission, one out of three reviewers left, had to find new reviewers which took several months, and the new reviewers took an additional month. The journal is too slow.)

棒棒来冲浪 2022-06-25

Just under review

棒棒来冲浪 2022-06-25

Did you send the manuscript to the recommended reviewers?

棒棒来冲浪 2022-06-25

2022 06 15 submit - This means that something was submitted on June 15, 2022.
2022 06 24 Under Review - This indicates that something is currently being reviewed as of June 24, 2022.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-06-25

@Fragments of Bear Biscuit: I only know that some reviewers will receive a month's worth of manuscripts and process them all at once, comparing them and only keeping the ones that are better.

YUANYUAN1231 2022-06-25

2022.06.24 accepted
The review was completed in less than three months, from March 28th to June 24th. It's quite fast for it to become popular this year. It could be luck or maybe the editor was kind.

ZZT123 2022-06-24

Brother, is your under review?

YUANYUAN1231 2022-06-23

2022.06.22 required reviews completed

越努力越幸运666 2022-06-23

I want to ask if all authors have agreed before with the editor. I didn't see any email confirming this. I want to know at which stage was this email sent?

超师傅 2022-06-23

Personally, I think you can't bring emotions either. The reviewers are not idiots. If you think this journal doesn't need innovation, then you're wrong!!!

胡椒粉 2022-06-22

I originally thought that all authors needed to agree before working with the editor, but I couldn't reach two of the authors. Therefore, without the consent of all the authors, I only agreed myself and started working with the editor on that day. Good luck, good luck!

菜鸡就是me 2022-06-22

What does it mean when the date with the editor changes twice after submitting the revised manuscript?

bakehuoen 2022-06-21

6.19 completed reject. 4 reviewers, 1 had no comments and is likely to be rejected directly, 3 reviewers had a total of 23 comments.

mzhx 2022-06-21

02/19 submitted
02/27 under review
03/17 under review
04/10 under review
05/03 required reviews completed
05/06 decision in process
05/07 major revision
05/26 revision submitted to journal
06/01 with editor
06/07 under review
06/11 required reviews completed
06/16 decision in process
06/19 accepted

Translation:
02/19 submitted
02/27 under review
03/17 under review
04/10 under review
05/03 required reviews completed
05/06 decision in process
05/07 major revision
05/26 revision submitted to journal
06/01 with editor
06/07 under review
06/11 required reviews completed
06/16 decision in process
06/19 accepted

awesome1111 2022-06-21

Update 6.16 with editor, why is it so slow? It has been with the editor for several days...

awesome1111 2022-06-21

Why is it so slow? It's been several days with editor...

我是一个小学生i 2022-06-21

It is necessary to have the consent of all authors before submitting the edits. At that time, as soon as I agreed, I immediately proceeded with the editor.

胡椒粉 2022-06-21

Same question? Submitted on June 17th, now it is also submitted to the journal.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started