nopiont0 2022-02-28

28-Oct-2020 Submission
09-May-2021 First round of minor revisions
08-Jun-2021 First round returned
28-Feb-2022 Accepted

After sending four reminder letters, people are exhausted.

Paper will be accepted 2022-02-28

May I ask how long it usually takes to receive news after the first review? Will the completed manuscript have a status of "required reviews completed"? Mine has been under the review status for over a month now.

大脸猫丷 2021-12-30

10.22 Submit - Submitted
10.25 Under Review - Under Review
12.01 Major Revision - Major Revision
12.16 a revision has been submitted - A revision has been submitted
12.20 Accept - Accepted

咿呀咿呦 2021-12-12

2021.10.25 Submission
2021.11.15 Minor revisions
2021.11.22 Submit revised version
2021.11.24 Acceptance
The submission period this time is very short, possibly due to the experiences from previous rounds, which accelerated the submission process.
We hope that everyone who is about to submit or is currently submitting will patiently wait and receive satisfactory results. We wish everyone good luck and continuous success in your submissions!

summer123- 2021-12-07

Does anyone know what it means when the status changes from "awaiting decision" to "under review"? Does it mean they are finding new reviewers again?

桔梗花 2021-12-06

It has been almost a month and there has been no progress. Although it shows "under review," the date has remained the same as the submission date. I'm not sure if the checklist Lumina is an editor or not, and I don't know if it has been submitted for review.

回头是岸 2021-12-06

In the fifth month of under review, a reminder email was sent. One month later, the journal replied saying that they have received only one reviewer's opinion so far and are still waiting for the opinions of other reviewers.

Ann_22 2021-12-05

May I ask which editor is ME in the system for everyone?

summer123- 2021-11-30

Have you reminded them to submit the manuscript? It has been two months since the first review, I dare not remind them.

summer123- 2021-11-30

It has been two months since the first trial, I dare not rush for the manuscript.

巧果果88 2021-11-26

I would like to ask, if JSFA does not accept, will the impact factor be the same when transferred to its sister journal, JSFA Reports?

zyg 2021-11-24

It seems like you are not the only one in a hurry. My first review has also taken over 4 months, and I'm hesitant about whether to urge for the manuscript or not. I'm afraid that urging for it might get rejected. It's really tormenting.

zyg 2021-11-24

Ah! Mine has also been under review for over four months. I am currently contemplating whether I should remind them or not, but I am afraid that reminding them will result in direct rejection. It is truly agonizing. Previously, I thought four months was long enough based on others' submission experiences, but seeing yours, I now realize that my waiting time may be even longer... I am really anxious.

回头是岸 2021-11-21

Submitted the manuscript on May 24, and the 5th reminder has been sent. It's now the 6th month and there is still no response from the first review. It's really delaying things and causing a lot of anxiety!

zyg 2021-11-18

Are all first trials slow? I'm so impatient. Does anyone have any good experiences to share?

zyg 2021-11-18

Are all first reviews so slow? I'm really anxious and in a hurry. I still don't dare to urge for the manuscript. Does anyone have any good experience?

zyg 2021-11-18

My submission has been under review for four months, and I'm feeling anxious.

Crystal 111 2021-11-14

I have been working on major revisions for 7 months. After completing the revisions, another month passed. Now, the status shows that the second round of review comments have been received, and I am currently editing them.

wang895677 2021-11-04

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to publish the paper online after acceptance? It has been 2 months since I received the acceptance, and it has been consistently showing the status "Awaiting Production Checklist."

wang895677 2021-11-04

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to publish online after the acceptance of the paper? It has been 2 months since I accepted it, but it still shows the status "Awaiting Production Checklist". I'm in a hurry.

zlfyzu 2021-11-03

May I ask how long you have been reviewing this?

子不语19899 2021-10-26

May I ask if there is any news about your paper now? Mine has been over four months as well.

Crystal 111 2021-10-25

Any updates? It's been almost half a month since I finished my repairs. Is the second review also taking a long time?

不爱生气的猪猪霞 2021-10-21

Exactly two months, without external review, directly rejected.

梨花梨花 2021-10-17

It has been half a month since the major revisions were submitted, but there has been no news at all. I am feeling very anxious.

爱吃蔬菜的西瓜 2021-10-13

I submitted it on September 10th, and it has been under review.

邀月独语 2021-10-05

Hello, may I ask if this journal has high requirements for innovation? Is it difficult?

jigolo 2021-09-26

Have you received a reply now? Mine has been pending for over half a year already.

summer123- 2021-09-26

Excuse me, have you made any progress? It has been under review for two weeks now.

Payne Hsieh 2021-09-24

under review includes with editor does not necessarily mean it has been sent for external review.