lp666 2023-06-17

Have you received any news about your manuscript review?

kikyou1994 2023-06-15

2023.6.6 submitted
2023.6.12 with editor
2023.6.15 under review

Hoping for a good outcome, please, please.

lp666 2023-06-08

There is no movement or sound at all.

lp666 2023-06-08

It has been almost three months since mine was also reviewed.

CV小白菜 2023-06-06

I haven't returned for four months since the first trial, and reminding several times along the way hasn't been effective.

redmery 2023-06-02

The status remains unchanged. I have already sent an email to inquire about it, but I haven't received a reply yet.

wyl 2023-05-30

Initial Date Submitted: 2023.3.10.

就像毕业 2023-05-27

Hello, may I ask if there are any results now?

lp666 2023-05-23

Okay, thank you! It has been two months since the first review of my paper and I still haven't received any news. I will wait for another month before reminding them again.

蒲哥哥 2023-05-22

The first review took over three months, with a slightly longer time for the editor, but it was quick after being under review.

lp666 2023-05-22

Hello, may I ask how long did it take for your paper to be reviewed for the first time?

蒲哥哥 2023-05-19

The review process is fast, the feedback is valuable, and the quality of the journal is good!

CV小白菜 2023-05-15

May I ask if you have received the result of the first trial now?

tangtangtang_1 2023-04-23

Hello, has the review been submitted? I want to ask about the overall speed of this journal.

tangtangtang_1 2023-04-23

Hello, what is your current status? I want to submit to this journal and would like to ask about the review speed.

灰灰dadada 2023-04-02

3.2 with editor
3.3 under review
3.11 under review

Translation:
3.2 is being reviewed by the editor.
3.3 is currently under review.
3.11 is also under review.

lvzhisheng 2023-03-24

It has been 72 days, and it has not been submitted for review yet.

MichaelCV 2023-03-19

The experience was very poor. There was a reviewer who did not respond throughout the process, so I waited for a long time and a new reviewer was added.

2021.6.25 Submitted
2021.6.26 With Editor
2021.7.21 Under Review
2021.9.23 Required Reviews Completed
2021.9.30 Decision in Process
2021.10.5 Major Revision
2021.11.18 Revision Submitted to Journal
2021.11.19 With Editor
2022.1.18 4.17 4.22 Under Review x3
2022.5.5 Required Reviews Completed
2022.6.27 Minor Revision
2022.7.25 Revision Submitted to Journal
2022.7.26 With Editor
2022.9.9 Decision in Process
2022.9.15 Completed - Accept

redmery 2023-03-17

2023.03.10 submitted to journal
2023.03.14 with editor
2023.03.16 Decision in Process
2023.03.18 reject, editor requested additional experiments and encouraged resubmission
2023.04.17 resubmission, submitted to journal
2023.04.22 with editor (Status Date 04.21)
2023.04.23 with editor (Status Date 04.22), status unchanged, but system date has changed, unsure of the situation
2023.05.16 decision in process, pill

ZHEN11 2023-03-16

Under review only after three months, if you want it fast, please don't invest.

xiaohuangwudiii 2023-03-03

We are still in the process of reviewing. I have urged the editor for our manuscript and was informed that one reviewer has already provided their comments, while the other reviewer is still in the process of reviewing. We are uncertain about the timeframe for completion. It has already been nearly 9 months now.

灰灰dadada 2023-03-01

2.28 submitted translates to "2.28 is submitted" in English.

灰灰dadada 2023-03-01

1.29 submitted: This means that something was submitted or turned in on January 29th.
2.9 reject: This means that something was rejected on February 9th.

CV小白菜 2023-01-27

with editor, it takes 61 days to review and approve.

Betrue 2023-01-18

with the editor to under review, it took 73 days... If you want it fast, absolutely do not submit!

CV小白菜 2023-01-15

I have also been with the editor for nearly two months.

CV小白菜 2023-01-15

It has been almost two months with the editor, still no news.

xiaomianyang 2023-01-11

How long have all of you been with the editor? I have been with them for almost three months.

Lyan 2023-01-11

Post on 2022/04/26
Hired on 2023/01/09
There was a minor revision in between, and then hired directly. It seems that the reviewer takes about a month to review, but most of the time is spent with the editor. It took a long time to find the reviewer, and after the review was completed, there was a long period of inactivity with the editor. Overall, the total duration was eight months, with each review taking one month, one month for revisions in between, and the remaining time spent with the editor.

suerxz 2023-01-08

Can the original poster provide an update? Does this mean that they were rejected?