认证评论 - Energy
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

宋周 2023-07-28

I submitted mine on the same day as you. The status changed once on 7.8, and it's still "with editor". I hope the review or rejection can be done faster.

保佑超超论文录取 2023-07-27

2023/7/27 avec l'éditeur

Translation: 2023/7/27 with the editor

lukas_wq 2023-07-27

What was the situation before the dip, bro? I also dipped.

duckkkkkkkk 2023-07-26

Already dipped

sunnyccshine 2023-07-26

Still with the editor, the status data has changed to 2023/7/24.

xiao luo! 2023-07-26

May I ask everyone if we still need to submit a word version with statistical word count when making revisions for the Energy journal?

薄荷Lee 2023-07-25

Rejected, the process was relatively fast, transferred to another option.

薄荷Lee 2023-07-25

7.24 transfer pending

kaisahw 2023-07-25

Has it become "Under Review" now?

伤心猪大肠 2023-07-25

Changed, submitted for review, but unable to invite reviewers.

早点毕业多发论文 2023-07-24

Excuse me, has the brother entered the dip stage?

大恐龙丨 2023-07-23

According to my knowledge, usually the decision is made based on the opinions of the reviewers combined with the editor's input. However, in most cases, the editor's decision should align with the reviewers' opinions, as the reviewers are experts in the direction of your paper.

You don't need to worry. If the editor has given you revisions, it means they acknowledge your work. Just butter up the reviewers and do well.

大恐龙丨 2023-07-23

There shouldn't be any big problems if you make a good change.

风起长林 2023-07-22

I am also a 7.3 with the editor.

灏夜 2023-07-22

Ah... this...

kaisahw 2023-07-22

Submitted on June 24, still with editor.

duckkkkkkkk 2023-07-22

7.3 Submission
7.4 with editor until now

灏夜 2023-07-22

Bro, how long have you been investing for?

小菜博 2023-07-21

2023.04.13 submitted to journal
2023.04.16 with editor
2023.05.07 under review
2023.05.08 under review Reviewer 1 received the manuscript for review
2023.05.09 under review Reviewer 2 received the manuscript for review
2023.05.09 under review Reviewer 3 received the manuscript for review
A total of 5 reviewers were invited, and 3 reviewers accepted the manuscript for review
2023.05.21 under review Reviewer 1 completed the review
2023.06.19 rrc No dip process
2023.06.30 major revised Several review comments, one-month deadline

保佑超超论文录取 2023-07-21

I still haven't received any news about my application, 11 days have passed since I submitted it.

宋周 2023-07-21

Is there any progress? My work has been with the editor all along, I don't know if I should wait for approval from the experts or if it is still being edited.

宋周 2023-07-21

Submitted on July 3rd, still with the editor.

早点毕业多发论文 2023-07-20

I am also from yesterday's RRC.

大恐龙丨 2023-07-20

After the same review, it should be rejected.

Based on the experiences of several friends who have submitted to this journal, if the result of the first review is a revision, the subject editor will directly provide you with the result after the revision; if the result of the first review is a rejection, the subject editor will send the result to the editor-in-chief for the final decision.

保佑超超论文录取 2023-07-20

2023/7/10 Submission
2023/7/11 with editor
2023/7/18 with editor

houkun 2023-07-20

What happened in the end? My dip has been 10 days already and there's still no news.

houkun 2023-07-20

I have been hesitant for a week now, I hope I didn't miss the chance to send it.

风起长林 2023-07-20

Has your current status changed? Or are you still with the editor?

jishuwen 2023-07-19

Under Review already, but I haven't received the track link. Does anyone know what's going on? The Elsevier customer service can check the status, but it's too troublesome.

薄荷Lee 2023-07-17

7.11: Submit
7.16: Decision in Process

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started