PhD Yan 2023-04-19

2023.04.19 Still Under Review
The review process was indeed fast, and at that time, I thought I would receive some news within two months. However, the manuscript has been stuck in the review process for such a long time.

qwes 2023-04-18

I also want to be able to receive the modified version as soon as possible.

云云云 2023-04-12

Your "under review" is too fast, I've been with the editor for over a month.

shuaibin 2023-04-10

2022.12.30 Submission
2023.1.4 Under review
2023.4.10 Still under review
It has been three months since the review process started, and I'm not sure if I should send an email to follow up.

qwes 2023-04-09

Is it always this slow now? I also want to win.

Mr Rong 2023-04-03

Please editor, give me a chance to make changes, I beg you.

Mr Rong 2023-04-03

20230401 translates to April 1, 2023.

zzzcsupm006 2023-03-25

Bro, which editor did you assign? It has been 20 days with mine.

Mr Rong 2023-03-25

20230325 Under Review
Thank you to the editor for giving me the opportunity to be reviewed. I beg the reviewers and teachers to give me a chance to make revisions! I'm begging you, please!

Mr Rong 2023-03-24

I hope to have the opportunity to submit for review! Please, I beg you.

云云云 2023-03-16

It is indeed a bit slow, I have been with editor for 20 days.

当局者迷 2023-03-16

The editor has been stuck for a month, reviewing for 40 days, and still in the process of reviewing, feeling exhausted.

云云云 2023-03-15

Hello, may I ask what is the current status of your submission?

云云云 2023-03-15

Hello, may I ask if your job is still with the editor?

sj1 2023-02-14

1.28 Submission
1.31 With Editor
2.1 Under Review
2.14 Required Reviews Completed
2.16 Required Reviews Completed

当局者迷 2023-02-07

I have been editing for a month after submitting.

未寻0825 2023-01-19

submit 2022-8-28;
with editor 2022-8-29;
with editor 2022-9-2;
Inquired about the status of the manuscript on 2022-10-15;
under review 2022-10-26;
major revision 2022-12-11;
Given three weeks for revisions, but contracted COVID-19 from 12-19 to 12-25, which made it extremely difficult. Had to request a one-week extension, and the Editor-in-Chief, David Young, kindly granted a two-week extension. Very grateful for the editor's kindness;
revision submit 2023-1-11;
with editor 2023-1-12;
under review 2023-1-16;
required review completed 2023-1-18;
accept 2023-1-19;
Sharing my experience and providing a reference for everyone. Personally, I suggest following up on the manuscript only if it exceeds two months. Editor Young is very kind and efficient.

小博 2023-01-10

2023.01.10 Rejected. Both reviewers had very negative opinions, stating that the experimental design was not rigorous enough and there was insufficient evidence in the discussion. However, neither of them explicitly recommended rejection. Nonetheless, the editor decided to reject it.

小博 2023-01-10

It will be reviewed and approved in less than two weeks, feeling a little anxious.

小博 2023-01-10

2023.1.7 required review completed

Translation: The required review has been completed on January 7, 2023.

小博 2023-01-09

Can the editor still choose by themselves?

祈祷早日毕业的学渣 2023-01-06

The Required Reviews were completed on December 31st, but there has been no update since then. I'm getting really nervous.

vvvvvvvggggg 2023-01-03

Hello, I would like to ask. Which editor did you submit to? I am also planning to submit, but I don't know which editor is good to submit to. It's my first time submitting and I don't have much experience.

bei123 2022-12-29

My editor is still with me, it has been one and a half months, congratulations.

小博 2022-12-27

12.26 Finally under review.

小博 2022-12-24

Envy, why is mine still "with editor" after more than two months?

祈祷早日毕业的学渣 2022-12-23

11.20 submission
12.6 under review
12.13 under review

小博 2022-12-21

2022.12.21 still with editor

BabySun 2022-12-11

Very fast, so fast that it's astonishing.. After one day of submission, they suggested that I submit to another journal in a different field.

小博 2022-12-07

This journal is so disgusting. They should have rejected it earlier. I submitted it on October 10th, and it has been almost two months now. After reading about your experience, I feel like I'm going to end up the same way as you.