小12345 2023-07-19

5.17 with editor
7.17 Under review

It took two months for external review, and at one point, I wanted to withdraw the submission. Luckily, it finally underwent external review, and I hope for a positive outcome. After the external review, the editor will send an email, allowing me to track the progress of the manuscript and see the comments and feedback from the reviewers.

两年 2023-07-11

Brother, what is the result?

张嘿dark 2023-07-10

7.3 Submission
7.7 With Editor
7.8 Decision in Process

able. 2023-06-28

I'm not sure either. Hopefully, good luck.

jin2468 2023-06-28

Hello friend, I am now in the same situation. After "with editor," it went straight to "decision in process." Does that mean it will be rejected? How is the situation with your article?

jin2468 2023-06-28

Friend, I submitted this, but it hasn't been reviewed yet. It went directly into the decision-making process, and it has been several days already. Does this mean it will be rejected?

able. 2023-06-27

Has anyone recently submitted? I have been in review for over half a month, and now it has been several days in "Decision in Process".

城门楼子 2023-05-01

Dragged on for over a month, with no reviewers available. I suggest submitting to another magazine under the same publisher, as it seems they have accumulated too many manuscripts during graduation season. In any case, the efficiency of this magazine is very low. If the reviewers don't respond, they won't follow up either. We can only wait slowly. There have already been comments on other platforms about the slow speed of this magazine, and I blame myself for not doing enough research beforehand.

鲜柠不加糖 2023-04-24

Submitted on 2.23, rejected for external review on 4.24, reason: no reviewer for the manuscript.

鲜柠不加糖 2023-04-21

Follow A.S.V.R Scientific Research Publishing Service on WeChat, just click on the customer service for assistance.

冒泡泡的苏打水 2023-04-18

Hello, may I ask how to check it?

鲜柠不加糖 2023-04-14

Hello, may I ask if you knew the editor in charge at that time? I want to urge my manuscript, but I can't find the place to send emails.

鲜柠不加糖 2023-04-11

Today I checked and found that it took 41 days for review, and I invited 3 reviewers, but no one has accepted the review yet.

城门楼子 2023-04-02

The speed is too slow. You've calculated it well. I have been waiting for an editor for a month now. Even after urging, I only received an official reply.

鲜柠不加糖 2023-03-27

May I ask how long it takes for the submission to be reviewed recently? It has been under a month for me.

小方的打工仔 2023-03-21

Brothers, after twelve days under review, the decision is now in process. It has been five days since then and there is still no news. Does this mean it's not going well? I'm anxious.

Ricky_Chen_JLU 2023-02-28

Oh... You are already considered fast. I submitted mine in June last year, and just received it a few days ago.

Ricky_Chen_JLU 2023-02-28

The review process does take quite a long time.
Submitted on June 17, 2022, but was rejected due to some information issues.
Resubmitted on June 20, 2022.
With editor on June 22, 2022.
Under review on June 23, 2022.
Two reviewers on February 2, 2023, and minor revisions were requested.
Revised manuscript returned on February 12, 2023.
Rejected on February 15, 2023, due to improper highlight format and excessive word count.
Resubmitted on February 15, 2023.
With editor on February 18, 2023.
Under review on February 20, 2023.
Accepted on February 25, 2023.
Online proof on February 26, 2023.

张Dr 2023-02-11

Is Colloids and Surfaces B now a top journal?

与姬共舞 2023-01-31

Submitted on January 20th, the status of the submission is still "Submitted to Journal". The process seems to be a bit slow.

宇燮 2023-01-26

2022.11.26 submitted to journal
11.30 Technical review did not pass, exceeded the number of images, and exceeded the word count
12.3 Returned for format modification, returned on the same day with editor
12.7 Under Review
2023.1.3 Required reviewers completed
1.5 Revision (Three reviewers, many and professional issues with the article details, added two characterization experiments, given three weeks for revision)
1.13 Uploaded revised manuscript (submitted to journal)
1.15 With editor
1.16 Under Review
1.24 Under Review (date changed once in between)
1.26 Accepted

Experienced one format modification, two rounds of under review, from submission to acceptance in a total of two months. Thank you to Professor Zhou, the editor from China, for efficiently handling the manuscript. The speed was quite fast! It was a very good submission experience. The editors were genuinely responsible and had strict requirements for manuscript format and image quality. Currently, it is a top journal in the second district of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, with an impact factor of 5.999. I wish the journal continued success!

油焖小龙虾 2022-12-27

It's just very slow, sigh, especially the editor from Israel. There is a post about this editor on Xiaomuchong.

油焖小龙虾 2022-12-27

Just let the system send it, then you can ask who is in charge of editing your article, and then send a reminder to the editor.

竹林风 2022-12-26

May I ask through which channel you sent the reminder letter? Mine was sent via email through the contact feature in the submission system.

竹林风 2022-12-26

I am also very slow, I submitted it on December 1st, and it didn't change to "with editor" until the 8th after urging. It's still like this now, why is it so slow?

油焖小龙虾 2022-12-24

Posted on 8.30, submitted for review on 10.7, with the editor for a month. It is said that this Israeli editor is very slow. Received the first review message on November 20, and waited for over two weeks in the editor's hands to complete the review. Revised on December 1 and accepted on December 9. Sent two reminders in between to get a response, but it was not personally handled by the editor, but by someone under the editor who dealt with the reminder letter. The Israeli editor is cautious in selecting.

滚滚的滚滚 2022-12-19

Does the word count of 6000 include the references?

xiaoxingyun1111 2022-12-12

After the external audit, how long does it take for the editor to make a decision when the required reviews are completed?

xiaoxingyun1111 2022-12-12

How long does it take for the status "Required Reviews Completed" after external review? When will the editor be able to make a decision?

孟德斯鸠 2022-10-22

August 19 submission, August 21 with editor, August 21 under review, September 8 revision, September 29 revision back, October 6 with editor, October 7 under review, October 22 accepted. Thank you to editor Alyssa Panitch for the recognition of the article! The article is required to be no more than 6000 words in length.