认证评论 - Chemical Engineering Journal
懵逼树下懵逼果 2021-03-11
Total time taken: 70 days!
Submitted to journal on 2020.12.21
With editor on 2020.12.25
Under review on 2020.12.29
Major revision on 2021.01.15
Submitted on 2021.02.01
Minor revision on 2021.02.17
Resubmitted on 2021.02.21
Accepted on 2021.03.01
The first submission was to JMCA, but it seems that JMCA may not have as much potential as CEJ, so the second submission was transferred to CEJ.
That's how my graduate student life ends, and now it's time to start working... Best wishes!
zhong888 2021-03-07
21.01.05 submitted to journal - Submitted to the journal on January 5th.
21.01.07 with editor - Under review by the editor on January 7th.
21.01.08 under review - Under review by reviewers on January 8th.
21.01.24 major revised - Major revisions were requested on January 24th.
21.02.18 re-submitted - Re-submitted on February 18th.
21.03.05 accepted - Accepted on March 5th.
The process from submission to acceptance took 2 months. During this time, there was a month given for major revisions. The three reviewers were very professional and their questions were insightful. I worked hard to complete any experiments that could be done within a month, and explained in detail the reasons for not being able to complete others. I initially thought there would be another round of revisions, but unexpectedly it was accepted smoothly. I sincerely thank Editor David Nisbet for his efficiency and hope the journal continues to improve.
必中666 2021-03-07
21.2.17 submitted to journal
21.2.19 with editor
21.2.20 with editor
21.2.26 under review
21.3.6 required reviews completed
Translation:
21.2.17 - Submitted to the journal
21.2.19 - Under the editor's consideration
21.2.20 - Still with the editor
21.2.26 - Under review
21.3.6 - Required reviews completed
good luck 2021-03-05
Hello, my funds can only be searched for in National Natural Science Foundation of China (国自然), and cannot be found in other places. You can manually input the information and then check if you input correctly. Sometimes, I accidentally click on the automatically popped-up option without paying attention.
I have never encountered a situation where manually inputting cannot be saved, so you should be able to proceed to the next step. You can try it multiple times.
lausijan 2021-03-04
May I ask what should I do if the fund cannot be retrieved when submitting a contribution, and manual input is not allowed for submission?
小学生111 2021-03-03
I have also been without an editor since returning the revisions to the journal for a long time, more than three months.
布衣书生 2021-03-03
Add me on WeChat for a private chat, 312596640.
koy12366 2021-03-03
Mine is also her, I submitted it for revision on the 12th, and I haven't received any updates so far.
布衣书生 2021-03-02
Excuse me, has anyone encountered an editor named Aiping Yu? My manuscript was returned on January 18th with four reviewers' comments (3 minor revisions and 1 major revision). The editor requested a major revision, but it was sent back for revisions on February 10th and is still "with editor" now. It has been 20 days already, why hasn't it been sent for review yet? I'm hesitant to rush them, but it's causing me a lot of anxiety. Please help by giving some advice.
good luck 2021-03-02
I hope the magazine will be better and better. What will be the impact factor in 2021? It was 10.6 in 2019. I predict it will be at least 13 in 2021. It took nearly two months in total. Let's all work hard together!
good luck 2021-03-02
Just a little note,
Submitted on January 8, 2021.
Received reviewer comments on January 23, with 4 minor revisions and over 30 comments in total. The reviewer's evaluation was good, and the editor gave a month for major revisions.
Returned with revisions on February 8, 2021.
Received reviewer comments again on February 23, with 2 very minor issues.
Replied to the comments on February 26.
Accepted on February 28.
Completed acceptance on March 1.
Prozac 2021-03-01
If it's for graduation, it's fine as long as the article has a DOI number. It doesn't necessarily have to have the year, volume, and issue number.
巴巴多斯岛居民 2021-03-01
Could you please tell me if there is any solution? I am about to graduate and I need to find a job using my thesis. I am a little anxious.
运 2021-03-01
I am too, I haven't received the issue number yet.
巴巴多斯岛居民 2021-03-01
From the manuscript to today, it has been three whole months and the issue number has not been released yet. May I ask if any friends have encountered this situation before and how to resolve it?
米兰的小铁匠2021 2021-02-24
Yes, everyone will be invited.
Keen111 2021-02-24
Can I ask if CEJ will invite everyone they hire to do a cover? What are the chances of being accepted after doing a cover? How much money do you need to pay after successfully being selected for a cover?
cyzw 2021-02-23
Customer service link: https://service.elsevier.com/app/chat/chat_launch/supporthub/publishing/
Keen111 2021-02-23
Hello, I want to know how to export such detailed process dates?
飞天小土豆 2021-02-23
2020.11.26 submitted to journal
2020.11.30 with editor
2020.12.08 under review
2021.01.12 major revision
2021.02.07 revision submitted to journal
2021.02.09 required reviews completed
2021.02.16 accept
Translated:
2020.11.26 submitted to journal
2020.11.30 with editor
2020.12.08 under review
2021.01.12 major revision
2021.02.07 revision submitted to journal
2021.02.09 required reviews completed
2021.02.16 accept
布衣书生 2021-02-22
May I ask what the customer service email is? I submitted my contribution for review ten days ago, and after twenty days, I received feedback with suggestions for major revisions (three minor revisions and one major revision). It has already been 11 days since I made the revisions, and it is still marked as "with editor". I am in a hurry.
cyzw 2021-02-22
With the editor for a month, I couldn't resist anymore. After overcoming the urge to rush the submission, it was sent for review the next day. I also have no idea about the editor's situation.
meizijiu26 2021-02-22
First, I submitted to AFM and ACS Nano and both were rejected. Then, I submitted to CEJ at the end of September. In mid-November, I received initial review comments, with a total of 7 reviewers - 5 minor revisions and 2 major revisions. The editor gave me one month to make the revisions. It took around 25 days to complete the revisions and then the manuscript went for a second review with 4 reviewers. Two reviewers agreed to accept the paper, while the other two raised a few more questions. It took about 10 days to complete the second round of revisions. On February 11th, the editor notified me of acceptance, and on February 17th, the article was published online. Overall, the experience was that there were a lot of reviewers and the process took a long time. I would like to thank editor Aiping Yu.
xmf123 2021-02-22
I also became "under review" again today. Did it get sent for external review again?
jiafeimao123 2021-02-20
Brother, your luck is so bad! You encountered three terrible reviewers, and they all distorted the manuscript. So, what's the situation now? I hope you can win the JMCA.
Right 2021-02-20
Instantaneous IF=12.791
GZUSS123 2021-02-20
No, I just want to know the immediate impact factor score.
果然是我 2021-02-19
How did you reject it? I just submitted it for review.
果然是我 2021-02-19
Boss, was your article rejected after review or directly rejected?
GZUSS123 2021-02-19
Now, what is the value of the instantaneous impact factor of CEJ?
Create your own webinar
Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.
Create NowAsk a Question. Answer a Question.
Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.
Get Started