年轮 2022-04-10

Hello. I want to ask how long it takes for your chief editor to handle the submission after it's been with them, and if there are any reminders in between. I submitted on March 1, 2022, and it has been "With Editor in Chief" status until today, March 10.

weijiangbo 2022-04-09

It is possible that an opinion was returned, that's all. My return for a major overhaul will take about two months.

ddggll 2022-04-08

It is estimated to be delivered into the hands of the Indians.

冷月无痕2 2022-04-08

It's been too long, 5 months have passed, and at least the review comments should have come back. It has been over a month for me and there is still no progress.

ddggll 2022-04-06

For the past five months, I have been constantly in contact with the editor in chief regarding submission, but they have not responded to any of my reminders/messages.

frgjfrghfsgh 2022-04-06

My required reviews were completed, but a week later it changed back to "under review". May I ask if anyone knows what this situation is?

冷月无痕2 2022-03-29

It's been over a month without any news from the editor in chief. Any netizens willing to share?

IamAReader 2022-03-27

BOGE's review requirements are becoming increasingly strict now, and the workload must be sufficient. The impact factor is currently 4+ and the future upward trend looks promising.

WMW1 2022-03-21

Excuse me, may I ask if the journal "Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment" has accepted my submission? Will they send an email for me to revise the manuscript before publication? Regarding the non-open access option, will the journal send me an email for selection or do I need to arrange it myself at the journal's location?

WMW1 2022-03-21

May I ask, for this journal "Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment," once accepted, will they send an email to request the final draft before publishing? Is it the journal's responsibility to email me for selection if it is not open access, or do I have to go to the journal's office myself to arrange it?

zhanglei 2022-03-17

Excuse me, how long have you been with the editor?

李胖吃鱼 2022-03-16

Submitted in January, feedback returned in July, sent back for revision in the same month, accepted in December, without any reminders throughout the entire process. Is there a possibility for this journal to be upgraded to Tier 2?

zhanglei 2022-03-14

I have been with the editor since 2.20, and my status has remained unchanged.

zhanglei 2022-03-14

The assistant editor sent an email on February 20th and is still with the editor. Can you please let me know approximately how long it takes for the review process? It is already past February 20th and the manuscript has not been submitted for review. Can I request an update?

小李想发SCI 2022-03-14

Hello, may I ask if you directly sent the email to the editor-in-chief Wong (lnywong@hku.hk)? It has been two months since my status changed from external review to decision in process. I have emailed Gowsika Rengaraj (assistant editor) several times, but the response was always that it is under subject expert evaluation. Can I directly ask the editor-in-chief about this situation?

Mining and Rock Mechanics 2022-03-02

My decision is still in process and was given on January 10th, and there has been no change until now.

暗箭 2022-03-02

After sending an email to Professor Wong, Professor Wong forwarded the email to Professor BASU, who promptly handled it that evening and provided a major revision. The revised version was due to be returned on the 24th, but it was discovered that the version submitted was incorrect. Another email was sent to Professor BASU, and on the 26th, it was sent for external review.

Mining and Rock Mechanics 2022-03-01

My situation is also like this, it has been a month and a half.

Mining and Rock Mechanics 2022-03-01

The translation of the text "decision in process 一个多月啦。。。。。。" from Chinese to English is:

"It has been over a month in the decision-making process..."

sevenup_ 2022-02-24

Submitted on January 7th, met with the editor-in-chief on January 12th, waited until February 20th for a response, and then sent an email to the Indian editor. However, the submission was directly rejected.

小李想发SCI 2022-02-23

Congratulations, host! My reviewing efficiency has significantly decreased, and every change in my state relies on reminders. Up until now, it has been over a month since the external review came back with "decision in process," and there is still no news. I sent an email asking for patience. Sigh! Graduation is approaching.

quanuquan 2022-02-22

2021.11.2 Submitted
2021.11.18 Format revised
2021.11.18 Format revised and resubmitted
2021.11.27 Under review
2021.12.14 Major revisions by two reviewers
2022.1.12 Revised
2022.1.22 Accepted
Overall, I was very lucky and the review process was really fast. The speed of the review process greatly depends on the reviewers. I am very grateful to the editor and the reviewers!

明天 2022-02-22

You have encountered an Indian editor, Indians have low efficiency.

cxx0226 2022-02-13

It has been a month, and there has been no response at all.

Superman 2022-02-08

It has been 10 days with the editor-in-chief, why is it so slow?

sevenup_ 2022-02-07

Have you received any updates? I haven't changed since January 11, 2022, with the editor-in-chief.

小李想发SCI 2022-01-28

Why does the status change to "decision in process" and still have to wait for so long... shouldn't this status mean that the external review results have come back?

明天 2022-01-27

Posted on September 23, 2021
Major revision on December 1st, with 12 comments from 2 reviewers. Both reviewers seem to be foreigners, and their comments are very professional.
Revised manuscript returned on December 29th.
Accepted directly on January 25, 2022.
Discussing my own submission experience: Although I have also submitted to EI and SCI journals in both China and abroad, it is obvious that foreign journals are much more formal. The main difference lies in the reviewers and editors. Foreign reviewers (including Chinese reviewers) will provide rejection comments in a very professional manner. It is clear that they have carefully read your paper and their comments are very insightful. It is difficult to respond, as I took 3 days to answer one comment from a reviewer when I submitted to BOEG. You know they are right, but it is just hard to respond.
On the other hand, some Chinese EI journals have impolite reviewers who quickly make comments without much thought. If they don't want to review, they can simply decline, but they should not make baseless claims.

小李想发SCI 2022-01-22

Now it is still a decision in progress, and the person I contacted was the editorial assistant.

烟波风雨 2022-01-19

Excuse me, has the process of "Decision in process" ended for you? It has been over two weeks for me and I still haven't received any updates.