少年与梦- 2023-02-21

2023.2.20 Under review again, for the fourth time. It's so slow. What's the situation?

Slittle-pepper 2023-02-17

Excuse me, did you accept it? How long did it take to process after the revision? I feel like this journal is so slow...

少年与梦- 2023-02-06

2023.2.5 under review, I don't know what's going on, the date has changed again.

少年与梦- 2023-01-24

2023.1.21 under review translates to "January 21, 2023, under review" in English.

少年与梦- 2023-01-16

2022.12.23 submitted.
2022.12.24 sent back to authors (Need to complete the conflict of interest questionnaire and upload the corresponding files in the submission system)
2022.12.24 submitted.
2022.12.25 with editor
2023.1.1 revise (Editor-in-Chief Prof. Adam F. Lee provided comments and gave one month to make revisions, mainly regarding supplementary bulk and surface quantitative chemical composition, as well as XPS issues)
2023.1.12 manuscript-R1 revision submitted
2023.1.13 with editor
2023.1.14 under review

something 2023-01-12

Sent wrong, it is Applied Materials today!

something 2023-01-12

Waited for a month, but the lack of innovation made me switch.

7982 2023-01-11

2022.12.20 with editor
Still in the same state after 22 days, too slow.

今晚吃鸡 2022-10-27

3.10 Submission
4.16 Feedback received, minor revisions
9.24 Returned for modifications (did not have time to make changes for a few months, applied for an extension)
10.25 Accepted
The editing efficiency is quite high, and the three reviewers are knowledgeable. They raised a dozen minor issues, and the reviewers were also quite efficient.

一枚大头 2022-10-25

10.20 under review, time changed once...

一枚大头 2022-10-25

Hello, I would like to ask, after the reviewers of the first review have replied with their comments, will "under review" automatically change to "required reviews completed"?

jiajia8686 2022-10-23

Just updating the date, seems to be anxiously searching for reviewers.

122 2022-10-23

7.21 submitted to the journal
7.22 with editor
7.30 under review
9.28 Review comments returned, two reviewers, minor revisions (under review changed multiple times, possibly due to finding new reviewers)
10.20 Revised
10.23 Accepted

一枚大头 2022-10-20

0727 Submission
0822 First review, two minor revisions, eight comments each
0907 Rework
0925 Under review, date changed once

It has been over a month since the rework, still no news...
Feeling anxious, afraid of a negative outcome

一枚大头 2022-10-19

Hello, may I ask if there was a change of reviewer during the second review process that took more than four months?

一枚大头 2022-10-10

0727 Submission
0822 First review, two minor revisions, each with eight comments
0907 Rework
0925 Under review, the date has changed once
It has been over a month since the rework with no news. May I ask if you have received it now?

关山无月 2022-09-20

5.29 submitted to the journal
6.1 with editor
6.5 under review
7.14 major revision
8.7 modified and returned
9.8 under review
9.18 completed-accepted

122 2022-09-17

9.8 under review, only updating the date.

胖的跑不动 2022-09-06

I'm so fed up. It's been almost a month since the major revision, and there's still no news. I see everyone else sharing that their revisions were submitted and accepted directly, so why do I have to go through the reviewing process? Is the editor unsatisfied with my revisions? These two reviewers are also ridiculous. It's been almost a month since I submitted the revisions. Can they at least give a response on whether they are satisfied or not? They keep making people wait, it's just frustrating...

xxjlcl 2022-08-19

5.7 Submission
6.11 First review, three reviewers, minor revision requested twice, major revision requested once
6.26 Revised
7.11 Accepted

122 2022-08-10

7.21 submitted to the journal
7.22 with editor
7.30 under review

Translation:

The text was submitted to the journal on July 21st.
On July 22nd, it was received by the editor.
As of July 30th, it is currently being reviewed.

DX 2022-08-09

Has the review comments been received? My submission has been pending for two months without anyone reviewing it.

DX 2022-08-09

What's the situation now? My submission has been waiting for review for two months and no one has reviewed it yet.

DX 2022-08-09

No one has reviewed it yet, and I don't know why.

luobu 2022-08-05

Friend, have you received the revised manuscript?

DX 2022-07-31

My paper has not been reviewed yet, it has been submitted for 2 months.

wang@wangwang 2022-07-24

Is this a good investment?

学术闲人 2022-07-09

The article was submitted in March, and it took over a month for revisions. It took more than two weeks to make the necessary modifications. After that, I had to wait for over a month again. In total, the whole process took over three months. The review process was relatively fast, except for the slightly slower editing phase.

chaosagent 2022-07-06

Proofread, new email today. I previously sent a proofreading email once, but my boss didn't see it. Oops, clicked wrongly and sent a comment. How do I delete it?

wwjChaos 2022-07-05

Excuse me, has the proofreading been done? It's been almost a month and I haven't received the proofreading email yet.