ZXNzxn1 2023-08-09

July 20-something, towards the end of the month, I can't remember the exact date.

jiazaihaibian 2023-08-07

Excuse me, on which day in July is the acceptance?

ZXNzxn1 2023-07-31

After reading others' experiences of submitting posts and being accepted, I would like to share my timeline with everyone for reference.

2023-01: Submitted for review
Around April, I received the first-round comments (the review process took less than three months)
Made minor revisions once
2023-07: Accepted as a regular paper
It took over half a year, and there were no changes in the status during the initial review period after submission. The handling by ADM was very fast, and the overall experience was quite good.

xxxxxxx3 2023-07-21

Why did this journal drop to zone 3? It has not yet entered the CCF directory.

Runx 2023-06-14

Share a timeline of an article recently submitted to TNSE, which took 8 months from submission to acceptance, with a total of 3 reviewers.
10-Aug-2022, Submitted
29-Dec-2022, Rejected and resubmitted
28-Feb-2022, Revised manuscript returned
31-Mar-2023, Minor revisions
18-Apr-2023, Accepted
Overall, TNSE's review process is quite meticulous, with the Associate Editor being very diligent and having a strong sense of authority.

zht411 2023-05-30

2021-08-13 Submit
2021-11-08 Reject
The first review took less than 3 months.
---------------------------
It is necessary to submit using the corresponding author's email.
AE Zuo Haochang is very kind, and responds to emails promptly.
The review speed is not fast, so be cautious when submitting.

阴天别闹了 2023-05-11

The first review process was still quite fast, with nine reviewers! Two of them were negative, and the editor rejected the manuscript. Most of their negative comments were meaningless in terms of improving the quality of the paper, such as the requirement for experiments or theoretical innovation. If the journal demands these criteria, I won't submit to it anymore. ?

WZHANG` 2023-04-25

Complex networks and their application directions, which field should I choose to submit an article? Please reply, thank you very much.

Field 1: Network Science Methods
Field 2: Mobile Networks and Network Learning
Field 3: Computer Networks
Field 4: Emerging Networks (such as energy networks, social networks, economic networks, transportation networks, and biological networks)

小薏米 2023-04-11

Hello, which one should I choose for the control direction?
Regular paper submission: Field 1: Methodology of Network Science
Regular paper submission: Field 2: Mobile Networks and Networked Learning
Regular paper submission: Field 3: Computer Networks
Regular paper submission: Field 4: Emerging Networks (e.g., Energy Networks, Social Networks, Economic Networks, Transportation Networks, and Biological Networks)

Stepeng 2023-03-27

I don't know why mine is OA.

Dr.X-M 2023-03-21

Hello, may I ask how many documents should be submitted when applying for a return? The submission system requires that the uploaded article PDF should not contain any colored or highlighted sections. Should I submit three files: a pure black version, a version with red annotations, and a response letter?

Stepeng 2023-03-20

3.1 Submission, May 15 - Reviewer's comments received, May 31 - Revision requested, September 11 - Accepted, Published on January 7.

maoxian1008675 2023-02-24

Posted on September 16, 2022
Major revision on November 12, 2022
Revised on January 31, 2023
Accepted on February 13, 2023
Overall, it was relatively fast. There were four reviewers, and one of them had sharp opinions. I made careful revisions and felt that the process was fast. I appreciate the speed of the reviewers and the associate and chief editors. The journal's recognition is still good, and I hope to upgrade to a higher tier next year.

sk8兔兔酱 2023-02-02

What does it mean that the name of ADM suddenly changed? Currently, it is still undergoing review. Previously, ADM has always displayed the same person's name on both lines, but today it was discovered that the name of the second line of ADM has been replaced by a different person, still undergoing review.

宇宙系浪漫 2023-01-11

Two lines of ADM and undergoing review have been submitted. Just wait for a few months for the "with editor" stage.

宇宙系浪漫 2023-01-10

"Excuse me, original author, after a paper rejection and resubmission, will it still be reviewed by the same peer reviewer?"

宇宙系浪漫 2023-01-09

Is the original reviewer still assigned to the paper after the author resubmits it following rejection?

薯条念经 2023-01-05

Rejection and resubmission, to be honest, I'm not quite sure if it's the same reviewer as before. From the comments, it's hard to tell, I can only say there are some similarities with the previous reviewer. The resubmission deadline was not specified.

宇宙系浪漫 2023-01-05

Hello, may I ask if it is a re-submission or the same reviewer as before?

博er 2022-12-29

Bro, is there a time limit for resubmission after rejection? Recently got the rejection result and considering resubmission.

薯条念经 2022-12-13

2022.2.28 First submission
2022.5.30 Rejected and resubmitted
2022.8.15 Resubmitted
2022.10.23 Minor revisions, mainly fixing some grammar issues. This review was quite quick.
2022.11.15 Submitted. It has been almost a month and there is still no result.

博er 2022-12-13

May I ask what is the current result of your thesis?

小新的爷爷糖 2022-11-29

Has Brother Xiaoxiu returned? My Xiaoxiu returned almost 6 months ago, and then gave another Xiaoxiu to revise the format and grammar. Another month has passed.

岂曰无衣 2022-11-21

11.3 submit undergoing review
11.21 undergoing review
Can I ask if "undergoing review" means it has been submitted for external review or is it still in the hands of the editor?

researcher_china 2022-10-29

I also have two acceptances, one minor concern (only one comment left), and it has been almost four months since it was sent back for repair.

宇宙系浪漫 2022-10-28

Is there only one status of "undergoing review" after submission? Does this status mean that it has been sent for external review? Are there any other status changes during the process?

小新的爷爷糖 2022-10-28

Wait patiently, I have two incoming, one minor repair, waited for 6 months.

宇宙系浪漫 2022-10-21

Is there only one status "undergoing review" after submitting the manuscript? Are there any other statuses in between?

askdjaslkdjl 2022-10-17

The first review took 5 months, with a request to revise and resubmit. After making the revisions and resubmitting, another 5 months have passed. The current status is with the editor. The reviewing process is much slower compared to when my senior submitted to this journal. It is really slow now.

薯条念经 2022-10-06

Will it be cold to be with the editor in less than two months?