认证评论 - Frontiers in Earth Science
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

独家丶季忆 2022-07-12

You don't need the corresponding author's email, you can complete all operations with your regular email, without logging into the corresponding author's account.

禾沐 2022-07-11

Do I have to submit the manuscript using the corresponding author's account?

禾沐 2022-07-11

Do I need to proofread the article before submitting it?

独家丶季忆 2022-07-05

As long as you submit original research, you will receive 2950 euros.

小学渣 2022-07-01

May I ask how much is your page fee? I noticed that different types of articles have different fees.

科研小小@ 2022-06-08

I recently submitted an article to this journal, and the initial review process went relatively smoothly. It was submitted on April 14, 2022, and the review was completed on May 18, 2022. Now, I am waiting for the associate editor to make the final decision, but this step has been delayed for three weeks. I'm wondering if anyone has had a similar experience and would appreciate if you could share your thoughts.

Does this mean that the article will be rejected? If the journal decides to reject it, will they continue to delay and not respond?

Oooliviaaa 2022-05-25

Released an album once, the speed is slower than the regular publication, about 2 months.
January 11, 2022: The article is accepted for publication.
January 9, 2022: Corresponding author resubmitted.
January 6, 2022: Guest associate editor requested corresponding author/contributor to revise the manuscript.
January 4, 2022: Review by editor 2 is finally confirmed.
January 3, 2022: Corresponding author resubmitted.
November 26, 2021: Review 1 has been completed.
November 19, 2021: Corresponding author submitted the manuscript.

Oooliviaaa 2022-05-25

The submission was made on April 28th, and the first-instance opinion came back on May 9th. One was accepted after modification, and the other required minor revisions. It was resubmitted on May 16th and accepted on May 20th.
There was no submission for an album. The submission process, as well as the speed of handling by the editor and reviewers, was very fast, and the feedback was also friendly.
Graduating smoothly without any issues is a good choice. Currently, the journal's reputation is also acceptable.

KSS 2022-05-06

I also saw similar evaluations under applied sciences-basel! Who are they trying to deceive here?

奔跑2020 2022-05-05

I don't have any specific requirements for polishing, it depends on the situation, it's not necessary.

这个期刊版面费真贵 2022-04-26

I have been serving as an editor for this journal for a long time now. The journal has a decent reputation in the open-source community and is listed in the third zone of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. Our usual speed of review and handling is also acceptable. As long as we can find suitable reviewers, the initial review can be completed within two weeks, and the average acceptance cycle is about one month. However, when submitting manuscripts, it is important to pay attention to the theme, plagiarism check, formatting, language, and other issues. Do not get rejected due to these basic problems and waste time. If there are any questions, feel free to contact me via WeChat at scipersistence.

AaronHW 2022-03-22

This journal really resembles Scientific Reports. After submitting, English editing is mandatory. A few thousand dollars are gone just like that, not to mention the review fee. It feels like a journal designed to make money and generate income for the reviewing experts. It's very rubbish.

科研555鸟 2022-03-15

A rapidly growing OA journal with a wide range of categories, the submission direction is also very specific. There are 3 peer reviewers, and both the editors and peer reviewers are very nice. The publication is under real-name system, authoritative, without any negligence. The key point is that the self-citation rate is low, ensuring the quality and deserving trust!

明易 2022-03-10

Is it really a regular publication? How is the journal? I want to submit an article.

天堂鸟5349 2022-02-22

Why are some papers not indexed by WOS? What are the principles of this journal's indexing?

迈克尔瓜瓜 2022-01-20

Hello! May I ask how to upload modified review comments? I clicked "submit all comments" but it didn't go through.

天堂鸟5349 2021-12-28

Sent the wrong journal, sorry.

天堂鸟5349 2021-12-28

It seems that most of the articles in this journal cannot be found on the web of science. Moreover, the impact factor on WOS is from 2018. Everyone should not blindly submit articles.

沉迷学术 2021-12-22

Spicy Chicken Open Source Journal

天堂鸟5349 2021-12-22

This journal is 99% composed of special issues. When you open an article on the official website, there is always a "THIS ARTICLE IS PART OF THE RESEARCH TOPIC..." note in the top right corner. The quality of these articles is really hard to say, similar to supplementary issues in domestic journals. Articles that do not belong to these special issues are very rare. The review process is fast but strict, and the editors are also strict. I had to go through three rounds of revisions on the interactive platform. My article does not belong to any special issue, so I submitted it normally. I estimate that this journal will soon follow the path of Scientific Reports.

地学R 2021-07-23

The translation of the text into English is as follows:

"The speed is super fast. After external review, it took half a month to receive the revision comments. There were two reviewers, but their opinions were not very helpful. To be honest, the requirements were quite low. I made some casual changes for a few days and sent it back. It took ten days to receive the acceptance. This journal publishes various special issues extensively, but the quality of most articles is relatively low. The publication fee is also very expensive, $2950. It is still possible to submit even with a mediocre graduation."

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started