JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES

There are a total of 3 reviewers, with three rounds of revisions. In the first round, there were major revisions (two major and one minor). In the second round, there were minor revisions (one major, one minor, and one acceptance). In the third round, there were minor revisions (one minor and two acceptances). The paper was accepted and published after a total of 10 months. The review process for JGR-A is quite rigorous, with in-depth and meticulous questions raised, which indeed improved the quality of the paper. By responding well to the reviewers' comments, the paper will eventually be successfully published. Previously, I mainly published papers in JGR-B. This is the first time I have published a paper in JGR-A, and I feel very good about it. I will continue to publish papers in it in the future.

October 2020 submission
December 2020 major revisions after the first review (encountered an expert who delayed giving feedback until the end, unrelated to the journal's speed)
Returned after revisions in February 2020
Minor revisions based on the second review in April 2020
Returned after revisions in April 2020
Accepted directly after the third review in April 2020
The journal is excellent, a top-tier publication. The feedback from the reviewers was very professional and indeed improved the quality of the article. It took two months for all the revisions. It was my first submission to JGRA, and the experience was great. I will continue to submit in the future, hoping for continued good luck.