Ethics

Article Ethics

Machiavellian Variations, or When Moral Convictions and Political Duties Collide

Giovanni Giorgini

Summary: In this article, the author comments on Michael Walzer's essay and adopts a perspective tracing back to Machiavelli, arguing that 'dirty hands' is a real problem faced by politicians and cannot be avoided by refraining from politics.

JOURNAL OF ETHICS (2023)

Article Ethics

Dirty Hands as a 'Weapon of the Weak': 'Heroism', 'Aristocratism', and the Ambiguities of Everyday Resistance

Demetris Tillyris

Summary: This article explores a less-discussed aspect of conventional Dirty Hands (DH) analyses and argues that the phenomenon of DH can also be seen as a weapon of the weak, used by the marginalized and dispossessed to resist injustice. By examining the concept of "everyday resistance" and looking at examples from African-American history, the article offers a new perspective on the ethics of resistance in democratic politics, highlighting the connection between subterfuge and complicity.

JOURNAL OF ETHICS (2023)

Article Ethics

Targeted Killing, Assassination, and the Problem of Dirty Hands

Tamar Meisels

JOURNAL OF ETHICS (2023)

Review Ethics

A Systematic Review of the 2016 National Academy of Engineering Exemplary Ethics Programs: Revisions to a Coding Framework

Justin L. Hess, Alison J. Kerr, Athena Lin, Andrew Chung

Summary: Engineering ethics is an essential aspect of accredited ABET programs, but there is a lack of consistency in how ethics is taught and assessed. This study examines exemplary engineering ethics programs recognized by the National Academy of Engineering and revises a coding framework to identify trends in learning objectives, instructional strategies, and assessment strategies. The results show that ethical sensitivity is a common learning objective in all exemplars, and various instructional strategies are used. Assignments/homework and summative reflections are commonly used for assessment. The study provides practical suggestions for assessing engineering ethics instruction.

SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS (2023)

Article Ethics

Playing Brains: The Ethical Challenges Posed by Silicon Sentience and Hybrid Intelligence in DishBrain

Stephen R. Milford, David Shaw, Georg Starke

Summary: The integration of functional human neuron networks into a silicon computing environment is discussed using the case study of creating silicon-biological intelligence. By embedding the DishBrain system into a virtual game world, the system successfully learns to play 'Pong' and exhibits intelligent behavior. However, the creation of such hybrid, silicon-biological intelligence raises ethical challenges, particularly the risk of creating synthetic phenomenology.

SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS (2023)

Article Ethics

Slippery Slope Arguments as Precautionary Arguments: A New Way of Understanding the Concern about Geoengineering Research

James Andow

Summary: This paper explores the argument against pursuing geoengineering research and urges a new interpretation of these arguments as precautionary arguments. It suggests that these concerns should be taken seriously.

ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES (2023)

Article Ethics

Individual Responsibility to Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions from a Kantian Deontological Perspective

Marc D. Davidson

Summary: As a collective action problem, climate change is best addressed through coordination. Most moral philosophers agree that as political citizens, we have a responsibility to help establish such coordination. However, there is disagreement on our individual responsibilities as consumers to reduce emissions before coordination is established. From a Kantian deontological perspective, we have a perfect duty to refrain from activities that we would not perform if appropriate coordination were in place.

ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES (2023)

Article Ethics

Practice, Ethical Life and Normative Authority: The Problem of Alienation in Steven Vogel's Environmental Philosophy

Simon Lumsden

Summary: In "Thinking like a Mall," Steven Vogel argues that there is no authoritative nature independent of human standards, and our destructive practices have degraded the environment. To correct these practices, we need to become alienated from them and make democratic choices that align with our values. However, this paper suggests that there is a missing step in this process - understanding the broader social and institutional framework, "Ethical Life", and the normative change necessary to address alienation.

ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES (2023)

Article Ethics

Digital twins, big data governance, and sustainable tourism

Eko Rahmadian, Daniel Feitosa, Yulia Virantina

Summary: This paper proposes a documentation framework for the implementation of Digital Twin technology in smart and sustainable tourism. It addresses challenges such as compliance, communication, and trust by applying big data governance principles. Through case studies, the benefits of the framework in promoting stakeholder communication and enhancing trust and transparency in the use of big data are highlighted.

ETHICS AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Ethics

Rethinking Appropriateness of Actions in Environmental Decisions: Connecting Interest and Identity Negotiation with Plural Valuation

Christopher M. Raymond, Paul Hirsch, Bryan Norton, Andrew Scott, Mark S. Reed

Summary: Issues of interest, identity and values are interconnected in environmental conflicts. To address these challenges, a relational understanding of environmental ethics and the concept of 'appropriateness of actions' are introduced. Success factors for supporting appropriate actions include understanding context and identifying key stakeholders, surfacing diverse interests and building system-level trust, building empathy for different identities grounded in specific places, eliciting diverse values and seeking to understand their links to worldviews and knowledge systems, and seeking out appropriate actions.

ENVIRONMENTAL VALUES (2023)

Book Review Ethics

We Are Not Born Submissive

Amy E. White

JOURNAL OF VALUE INQUIRY (2023)

Article Ethics

Political Violence: The Problem of Dirty Hands

Christopher J. Finlay

Summary: This paper argues that political leadership often requires "dirty hands" due to its relationship with violence. Violent means create a dominating power, which conflicts with the proper goals of political action. This power often affects non-target individuals and empowers unscrupulous agents. The justifications for violence in politics are "supra-moral," motivated by the value of morality as a whole rather than specific moral values. The indeterminate importance given to these goals often leads to uncancelled negative consequences resulting from the evil of violence.

JOURNAL OF ETHICS (2023)

Article Ethics

Public health measures and the rise of incidental surveillance: Considerations about private informational power and accountability

B. A. Kamphorst, A. Henschke

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has led to increased reliance on private infrastructure and digital services in various sectors. This has granted private actors significant power and resulted in the emergence of digital surveillance practices. The paper argues that governments should ensure the justifiability of data disclosure and monitoring by private actors in public health emergencies, and regulate and oversee these private surveillance practices.

ETHICS AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Ethics

A Conceptual Framework to Safeguard the Neuroright to Personal Autonomy

Jose M. Munoz, Javier Bernacer, Francisco Guell

Summary: In this article, the main problems related to the neurorights of autonomous action are explored, specifically free will and cognitive liberty. A holistic interpretation of human actions is proposed as a possible solution. The article discusses conceptual and practical issues with the neuroright to free will, analyzes the origins and current status of cognitive liberty, criticizes mainstream action theory's concept of decision, and suggests a unified framework for interpreting cases involving neurotechnologies. The importance of introducing freedom of thought and personal autonomy as complementary neurorights is outlined.

NEUROETHICS (2023)

Article Ethics

Should we embrace Big Sister? Smart speakers as a means to combat intimate partner violence

Robert Sparrow, Mark Andrejevic, Bridget Harris

Summary: This article explores the potential use of smart speakers to detect and report intimate partner violence (IPV). The authors argue that the ethical and political considerations differ depending on whether the decision to develop or use this technology is being considered. They urge resistance to the development of this technology in order to avoid potential risks, or if it is developed, ensuring the involvement of victim-survivors from different demographics, as well as government and non-government stakeholders in shaping the technology and its regulations.

ETHICS AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Book Review Ethics

Person, thing, Robot: a moral and legal ontology for the 21st century and beyond

Abootaleb Safdari, David Gunkel

ETHICS AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Ethics

Philosophical Practice and Agassi's Approach to Practical Affairs

Ora Gruengard

Summary: Is Agassi's philosophy of practical affairs applicable in philosophical practice? It could be useful, but not suitable for all counselors. His critical rational approach requires prior awareness and may not always be relevant to the concerns of counselees.

PHILOSOPHY OF THE SOCIAL SCIENCES (2023)