Journal
EVOLUTIONARY BIOLOGY
Volume 38, Issue 2, Pages 144-162Publisher
SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11692-011-9110-2
Keywords
Integration; Modularity; Cambrian; Trilobites; Evolution; Morphometrics
Categories
Ask authors/readers for more resources
Phenotypic integration can influence evolutionary rate and direction by channeling variation into few dimensions. The extent to which that channeling serves as a constraint over macroevolutionary timescales is determined in part by the evolutionary lability of phenotypic integration. Evolutionary change in patterns of pleiotropy, potentially reducing that constraint, is thought to be more readily achieved when pleiotropy is structured by variation arising in parallel along different developmental pathways rather than by variation arising from direct interactions within and between those pathways. Herein we test two predictions that follow from that hypothesis: (1) that clades undergoing dramatic diversification are characterized by integration that is weakly influenced by direct interactions; and (2) that the structure of integration arising from direct interactions is more conservative than that arising from parallel variation. We examine integration of the cranidium of two Cambrian ptychoparioid trilobites, Crassifimbra walcotti and Eokochaspis nodosa, comparing them to each other and to a previously studied species, C.? metalaspis. Shape variation is decomposed into components representing variation among individuals and variation due to direct interactions. In all three species, variation among individuals was only weakly influenced by direct interactions, suggesting that integration was unlikely to have been a long-term constraint on the Cambrian diversification of ptychoparioids. Phenotypic integration of E. nodosa is no more similar than expected by chance to either Crassifimbra species, but the component due to direct interactions is more similar than expected by chance to that of C.? metalaspis. Conversely, the two Crassifimbra species are generally similar (although not identical) in phenotypic integration, but markedly differ in their structure of direct interactions. Integration arising from direct interactions was therefore not immune to restructuring over even short evolutionary timescales, and was not always more conservative than that arising from parallel variation.
Authors
I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.
Reviews
Recommended
No Data Available