Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) - The Novel Trend of Targeting Alzheimer's Disease in Its Early Stages - Methodological Considerations

While much uncertainty exists in the estimates of the global burden of Alzheimer's disease and about the potential impact of various interventions, there is a widespread acceptance of the fact that the steady increase in the incidence and prevalence of the condition worldwide is becoming a massive public health problem as well as a huge economic burden for all healthcare systems and societies. These heavy demands are further compounded by the poor quality of life of the affected individuals, of their families and of their caregivers. The epidemic proportion of Alzheimer's disease has triggered relentless attempts for development of treatment approaches during the past two decades by a multitude of pharmaceuticals and biotech companies. Commercial development of the acetylcholinesterase inhibitors has, until recently, virtually dominated the field and, although efficacy has been demonstrated for five different products, the long-term clinical results suggested that alternate approaches were warranted. Disease modifying strategies targeting the beta-amyloid plaques (e. g., decreasing beta-amyloid formation through beta- and gamma-secretase inhibition, diminishing beta-amyloid aggregation through anti-aggregants or enhancement of beta-amyloid clearance through active/passive immunization), targeting the neurofibrillary tangles through inhibition of tau protein hyperphosphorilation or, more recently, by increasing mitochondrial permeability, all these potential treatment modalities are facing major methodological challenges during the conduct of a myriad of clinical trials meant to bring the novel therapies to the market. Failure of more than 400 products tested in more than 800 clinical trials to date, with many of these failures occurring in late stage development (phase III) have triggered a paradigm shift toward targeting of the early stages of cognitive deficiencies (mild cognitive impairment-MCI) and a refinement of the investigative methodologies. The great heterogeneity of the disease entity itself (MCI) coupled with inadequate sensitivity, specificity and positive/negative predictive values of the many common diagnostic outcome scales, outcome measures, and of many of the currently used biomarkers expose the drug development professionals to the risk of methodological flaws rendering the products explored ineffective, while very expensive.