Validating a turbulence closure against estuarine microstructure measurements

A simple k-epsilon turbulence closure is introduced which has no stability functions but instead a Richardson number-dependent turbulent Prandtl number. Its free parameters are determined in a comparison with microstructure observations from a stratified and sheared tidal estuary and laboratory measurements. The closure is able to simulate observed turbulent dissipation rates (epsilon) and turbulent length scales (l(th)) in regions of strong mean shear and small gradient Richardson number (R-g) to within factors of 2-3. It fails in regions of small shear and large R-g presumably because of the dominance of internal wave-driven mixing. Additional simulations with a k-epsilon closure with stability functions taken from Canuto et al. [Canuto, V. M., Howard, A., Cheng, Y., Dubovikov, M.S., 2001. Ocean turbulence I: one-point closure model. Momentum and heat vertical diffusivities. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 31, 1413-1426] and with the closure of Baumert and Peters [Baumert, H., Peters, H., 2004. Turbulence closure, steady state, and collapse into waves. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 34, 505-512] show poor performance. Establishing a valid 1:1 comparison of simulated and observed epsilon and l(th) requires nudging the model velocity and density toward observed values because free model integrations quickly diverge from the observations. Steady state gradient Richardson numbers are constrained to a range of 0.18-0.25, while flux Richardson numbers are constrained to the range of 0.1-0.22. The closure output is rather insensitive to such parameter variations. The simulations are sensitive, however, to the treatment of the observed velocity and density used to nudge the model. Good closure performance requires averaging the measured tidal flow over about an hour, a time scale for which conventional numerical models of estuarine circulations should be able to match observed shears. In the closure simulations the TKE balance stays close to a production-dissipation balance. The time rate of change and vertical diffusion of TKE are small, of the same order of magnitude, and vary in magnitude relative to each other systematically across the water column. (C) 2007 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.