Phenocryst-poor rhyolites of bimodal, tholeiitic provinces: the Rattlesnake Tuff and implications for mush extraction models

We consider the origin of rhyolites associated with tholeiitic basalt in bimodal provinces, as exemplified by the Rattlesnake Tuff of the High Lava Plains of eastern Oregon, in comparison to rhyolites associated with calcalkaline suites in light of recent models of extraction of rhyolite from crystal mush (Hildreth, J Volcanol Geotherm Res, 136:169-198, 2004; Bachmann and Bergantz, J Petrol, 45:1565-1582, 2004). The High Lava Plains encompass a strongly bimodal, tholeiite-rhyolite suite, spatially and compositionally related to the Snake River Plain and Yellowstone Plateau. In our assessment we draw the distinction between fractionation dominated processes to make rhyolites from rhyolites and processes required to make the parental rhyolite melt. New isotopic data and compositional zoning profiles in phenocrysts confirm that crystal fractionation dominated the generation of progressively more evolved, discrete rhyolites in the zoned Rattlesnake Tuff and are consistent with an origin of the least evolved high-silica rhyolites by partial melting of a mafic crust. While the most evolved rhyolites are compositionally virtually indistinguishable from those of calcalkaline suites, the parental rhyolites from bimodal suites are more Fe-rich than their calcalkaline counterparts. Oxygen isotope thermometry yields pre-eruptive temperatures of 860 degrees C, in keeping with 800-880 degrees C zircon saturation temperatures. High magmatic temperatures are common among rhyolites of bimodal suites, distinguishing them from cooler rhyolites of calcalkaline suites. Extraction of interstitial melt from a granodioritic mush cannot produce compositions of the Rattlesnake Tuff on the basis of major and trace element arguments (especially Fe, Ba, Sr, and Eu) and on the basis of temperature considerations. Chemically viable parental crystal mushes are syenite and alkali (A-type) granites for the production of all more evolved Rattlesnake Tuff rhyolites; ferro-dacitic mush is required for production of the least-evolved, parental Rattlesnake Tuff rhyolite. Paucity of such ferro-dacitic compositions in tholeiitic bimodal suites, especially compared to the abundance of dacitic (granodioritic) compositions in calcalkaline suites, argues against the mush extraction model for the parental rhyolite. Furthermore, rhyolites of bimodal suites lack associated voluminous eruptions of crystal-rich ignimbrite that might represent a parental mush, as exemplified by the monotonous intermediate Fish Canyon Tuff in calcalkaline suites. We conclude that extensive fractionation is common among rhyolites and may obscure their ancestry. Fe-rich parental rhyolites common in bimodal tholeiitic suites, as represented by Rattlesnake Tuff, may often be the result of partial melting of mafic to intermediate crust, in contrast to calcalkaline high-silica rhyolites that are related to voluminous suites of intermediate intrusive rocks where the pre-plutonic mush-extraction model works better.