Differences in response to fetal hemoglobin induction therapy in β-thalassemia and sickle cell disease

Inducers of fetal hemoglobin (HbF) have shown considerable promise in the treatment of sickle cell disease (SCD). However, the same agents have shown less clinical activity in beta-thalassemia (beta-Thal). To understand the basis of these differences in clinical effectiveness, we compared the effects of butyrate and hemin on the expression of the different globin genes in progenitors-derived erythroid cells from patients with beta-Thal intermedia and SCD. Exposure to butyrate resulted in an augmentation of gamma-globin mRNA levels in both SCD and beta-Thal. Interestingly, butyrate exposure increased alpha-globin expression in beta-Thal, while alpha-globin mRNA levels decreased in SCD in response to butyrate. As a result, the favorable effects of the butyrate-induced increase in gamma-globin expression on alpha:beta-like globin mRNA imbalance in beta-Thal were reduced as a result of the associated increase in alpha-globin expression. Hemin had similar but less profound effects on all three globin genes in both categories of patients. Although the majority of patients with beta-Thal did not correct their globin imbalance in response to butyrate or hemin induction of HbF in a minority of patients resulted in marked reduction in globin imbalance. Thus, we believe that the poor clinical response in a majority of patients with beta-Thal to inducers of gamma-globin expression may be a reflection of unfavorable effects of these agents on the other globin genes. (C) 2009 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.