Noncorrelation between maximum life span and antioxidant enzyme levels among homeotherms: Implications for retarding human aging

A series of studies over many years has conclusively disproved the hypothesis that longevity in warm-blooded animals (homeotherms) correlates with high levels of antioxidant enzymes: in fact, these variables generally exhibit a strong negative cross-species correlation. in flies and nematodes, however, substantial extension of maximum life span has resulted from genetic manipulations that increase antioxidant enzyme levels; these manipulations have always been associated with increased resistance to oxidative challenge, indicating that the life span extension is directly caused by the raised antioxidant capacity. This stark contrast merits careful analysis because it casts doubt on the value of short-lived invertebrates as models for the investigation of mammalian aging. Here is it shown that these results imply the existence, in homeotherms but not in flies or worms, of life span-limiting pathways of oxidative damage that are impervious to enzymatic antioxidants. This is shown to lend weight to the currently controversial theory that somatic mitochondrial DNA mutations contribute significantly to determining the rate of aging of homeotherms, and thereby suggests a feasible intervention to retard human aging.