Separating the elements of habitat structure: independent effects of habitat complexity and structural components on rocky intertidal gastropods

It has been difficult to understand the effects of habitat structure on assemblages because the different elements of habitat structure are often confounded. For example, few studies consider that the effects of structural components of a habitat (rocks, trees, pits, pneumatophores) may be separate from the complexity (e.g. surface area (SA)) they create. From prior observations and experiments, I developed three hypotheses about the effects of habitat structure on gastropods on rocky intertidal shores in Botany Bay, Australia. (1) The complexity of habitats positively affects the density and richness of gastropods. (2) The fractal dimension (D) represents elements of complexity that affect the density and richness of gastropods better than other indices of complexity. (3) The effects of specific structural components on the density and richness of gastropods are independent of their complexity. To test these hypotheses, treatments composed of pits and pneumatophores were used to independently manipulate complexity and structural components in experiments repeated at five different times on two shores. There was support for hypotheses (1) and (3) at most times and places but not for hypothesis (2). Richness, total density, and the densities of two of the three most common gastropods were greater in treatments with greater complexity. D was not definitively better than other indices of complexity, but D and SA were recommended for further consideration. When complexity was held constant, species richness and the density of most gastropods, except Austrocochlea porcata, was greater in treatments with pits than with pneumatophores. A common mechanistic explanation for the effects of habitat complexity on rocky intertidal gastropods relies on a specific characteristic of pits; they pool water and reduce desiccation stress. This assumption may be appropriate for many gastropods, but it was inappropriate for A. porcata. Habitat complexity affected its density, but this was not because of a characteristic specific to pits. The complexity and structural components of habitats have separate effects on assemblages, and it confuses the study of habitat structure to combine them. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.