Chronic softening of cartilage without thickening of underlying bone in a joint trauma model

We have recently developed a trauma model to study degradation of the rabbit patello-femoral joint. Our current working hypothesis is that alterations in retropatellar cartilage and underlying bone in our model are initiated independently by acute overstresses developed in each tissue during blunt insult to the joint, and that the processes of chronic degradation in each tissue are not related in a mechanical sense. The current study was conducted in an attempt to help validate our hypothesis by impacting the patello-femoral joint with a padded interface. Based upon earlier human cadaver experiments, we believe this would reduce the acute overstresses in patellar bone while the stresses developed in the overlying retropatellar cartilage would be sufficient enough to initiate a chronic softening of the tissue. Twenty-four animals received an impact to the patello-femoral joint and were sacrificed at either 0, 4.5, or 12 months post-insult. Three acute animals were impacted to develop a simplified computational model to estimate the stresses in joint tissues. The study showed there was a significant softening of the retropatellar cartilage at 4.5 and 12 months post-trauma, compared to unimpacted controls. However, no thickening of the underlying subchondral bone was documented at any timepoint. This was consistent with a reduction of stress in the bone compared to earlier studies, which document thickened subchondral bone post-insult at the same applied impact load. In conclusion, this study helped validate our hypothesis by documenting chronic softening of cartilage without remodeling of the underlying subchondral bone. Furthermore, this study, along with our earlier studies, suggest that impact load alone, which is currently used by the automobile industry to certify new automobiles, is not a good predictor of chronic injuries to a diarthrodial joint, and that simply the addition of padding to impact interfaces may not be adequate to protect occupants from chronic injuries. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.