Using combinations of biocontrol agents to control Botrytis cinerea on strawberry leaves under fluctuating temperatures

Experiments were conducted with Botrytis cinerea on strawberry leaves to investigate where combinations of commercially available biological control agents (BCAs) might control B. cinerea more effectively than individual BCAs. Specifically, we studied the persistence of biocontrol activities, spread of BCAs among leaves, and biocontrol efficacy in relation to application regimes: mixed versus single BCA, pre-versus post-inoculation application, and sequential versus simultaneous application. Three BCA products (Sentinel, Serenade and Trianum) were used for this study. Overall, Serenade did not significantly reduce sporulation of B. cinerea on strawberry leaf discs whereas Sentinel and Trianum gave a similar and significant biocontrol efficacy. Biocontrol efficacy remained almost unchanged 10 days after application at 20/20 degrees C (day/night) or 24/16 degrees C temperature regimes. In contrast, reduced biocontrol efficacy at 26/14 degrees C suggests BCA survival was reduced under these conditions. Incidence of B. cinerea sporulation on leaf discs was ca. 60% higher on leaves that emerged after the BCA application than on leaves directly exposed to BCA, indicating insufficient amount of the BCA had managed to spread to new leaves. Combinations of BCAs, whether applied simultaneously or sequentially (48 h apart), did not improve disease control over the most effective BCA within the combination applied alone. This indicated possible antagonism or interference between the BCAs. Results suggested that there was significant antagonism for most combinations of the three BCAs tested and the degree of antagonism increased as the time from BCA application to pathogen introduction lengthened.