The role of positive charges on G-quadruplex binding small molecules: Learning from bisaryldiketene derivatives

Background: G-quadruplexes are promising therapeutic targets for small molecules. In general, the introduction of steady positive charges through the in situ alkylation of nitrogen atoms within potential G-quadruplex ligands can significantly improve their quadruplex binding and stabilization abilities. However, our previous studies on bisaryldiketene derivatives showed that the derivative M4, whose central piperidone moiety is quatemized, exhibits a poor G-quadruplex stabilization ability. Methods: To clarify this unusual finding, CD, ITC, UV and NMR analyses were performed to determine the binding behaviors of M4 and its non-quatemized analog M2 to G-quadruplex DNA [d(TGGGT)](4). Molecular modeling approaches were also employed to help illustrate ligand-quadruplex DNA interactions. Results: The CD melting and ITC analyses revealed that M2 exhibited much stronger stabilization and binding abilities to [d(TGGGT)](4) compared to M4. Moreover, the CD and ITC analyses in combination with UV, NMR and MD simulations revealed that M2 tended to be end-stacked on the G-quartet, whereas M4 tended to be bound in the groove region. Analysis of the electrostatic potential showed that the charged surface of M4 was more positive than that of M2 and other reported ligands that bind to the G-quadruplex via end-stacking interactions. Conclusions: The results indicated that the different positively charged surfaces of M2 and M4 might be the key reason for their different binding modes. These different binding modes also lead to different binding affinities and stabilization abilities for [d(TGGGT)](4). General significance: These results provide new clues for the rational design of G-quadruplex-binding small molecules with steady positive charges. (C) 2013 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.