Relationships between root characteristics and seed size in two contrasting floras

Plants vary greatly in root system characteristics, but the causes of this variation are poorly understood. We hypothesised that root system size is closely linked to the plant's ecological strategy, and that seed size is correlated with root diameter, as a result of, anatomical constraints. We analysed the relationships between root characteristics - root depth, basal root diameter and root type - and other plant attributes in more than 300 plant species from two ecologically and geographically contrasted areas: Britain and NE Spain. We used statistical tests that took into account phylogenetic patterns in the data. Apart from plant life span, only plant height and seed size were related to root size in the adult plants. Plant species with shallow or thin main roots had smaller seeds than species with deep or thick main roots, and species with taproots had bigger seeds than plants with fibrous or especially with adventitious roots. These relationships were consistent in the two floras. Seed size was related to plant height, but this association was weaker than that between seed size and root depth. Root depth explained a significant proportion of the variation in seed weight, independently from life form or dispersal mode and, in some cases, more than either of them. These results suggest that traditional ecological explanations do not adequately explain the relationship between seed and plant adult size, and that there will be other, complementary explanations. In particular, we propose that the relationship between seed size and plant height is secondary. The putative causal sequence is that deep-rooted plants (which are generally taller) have large seeds because of allometric and developmental constraints that mean that only large seeds can produce the thick roots that can grow rapidly to depth. (C) 2001 Editions scientifiques ct medicales Elsevier SAS.