Computational fluid dynamics modelling of boundary roughness in gravel-bed rivers: An investigation of the effects of random variability in bed elevation

Results from a series of numerical simulations of two-dimensional open-channel flow, conducted using the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code FLUENT, are compared with data quantifying the mean and turbulent characteristics of open-channel flow over two contrasting gravel beds. Boundary roughness effects are represented using both the conventional wall function approach and a random elevation model that simulates the effects of supra-grid-scale roughness elements (e.g. particle clusters and small bedforms). Results obtained using the random elevation model are characterized by a peak in turbulent kinetic energy located well above the bed (typically at y/h = 0.1-0.3). This is consistent with the field data and in contrast to the results obtained using the wall function approach for which maximum turbulent kinetic energy levels occur at the bed. Use of the random elevation model to represent supra-grid-scale roughness also allows a reduction in the height of the near-bed mesh cell and therefore offers some potential to overcome problems experienced by the wall function approach in flows characterized by high relative roughness. Despite these benefits, the results of simulations conducted using the random elevation model are sensitive to the horizontal and vertical mesh resolution. increasing the horizontal mesh resolution results in an increase in the near-bed velocity gradient and turbulent kinetic energy, effectively roughening the bed. Varying the vertical resolution of the mesh has little effect on simulated mean velocity profiles, but results in substantial changes to the shape of the turbulent kinetic energy profile. These findings have significant implications for the application of CFD within natural gravel-bed channels, particularly with regard to issues of topographic data collection, roughness parameterization and the derivation of mesh-independent solutions. Copyright (C) 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.