A trade-off between catalytic power and substrate inhibition in TCHQ dehalogenase

Tetrachlorohydroquinone (TCHQ) dehalogenase is profoundly inhibited by its aromatic substrates, TCHQ and trichlorohydroquinone (TriCHQ). Surprisingly, mutations that change Ile12 to either Ser or Ala give an enzyme that shows no substrate inhibition. We have previously shown that TriCHQ is a noncompetitive inhibitor of the thiol-disulfide exchange reaction between glutathione and ESSG, a covalent adduct between Cys 13 and glutathione formed during dehalogenation of the substrate. Substrate inhibition of the thiol-disulfide exchange reaction is less severe in the I12S and I12A mutant enzymes, primarily due to weaker binding of TriCHQ to ESSG. These mutations also result in a decrease in the rate of debalogenation. Because the rate-limiting step in the I12S and I12A enzymes is dehalogenation, rather than the thiol-disulfide exchange reaction, the relatively modest inhibition of the thiol-disulfide exchange reaction does not affect the overall rate of turnover.