Comparison of Biociphos-Plus® and TRIS-egg yolk extender for cryopreservation of bull semen

For optimizing routine freezing of bull semen. we examined three different cryopreservation methods using either TRIS-egg yolk-citrate extender or Biociphos-Plus(R). Biociphos-Plus(R) (IMV, France) has been marketed as an extender, in which egg yolk is replaced by a sterile soybean extract to reduce the contamination risk derived from animal borne substances. We used 78 bulls of various breeds (Brown Swiss, Holstein. Simmental) between 12 and 23 months of age, and we produced a total of 800-1000 straws (0.25 ml 20 x 10(6) spermatozoa) from each bull using three different methods. In method A. we used TRIS-egg yolk as extender and packaged at 4degreesC, In method B, we also used TRIS-egg yolk but packaged at room temperature (RT) between 18 and 22degreesC. In method C, Biociphos-Plus(R) served as extender and we packaged at RT. We compared methods A, B and C by using post-thaw motility, viability, morphology and osmotic resistance as semen quality parameters. In addition, we recorded 75-day nonreturn rates (NR75) to detect the effect of extenders on fertility. With the exception of primary defects, all laboratory parameters investigated were significantly (P < 0.05) better in methods A (TRIS-egg yolk, 4 C) and B (TRIS-egg yolk, RT), compared to method C Biociphos-Plus(R), RT). We recorded no significant difference between methods A and B. We could not verify the differing laboratory results by fertility data (NR75). However, when we analyzed NR75 for a single breed, significant (P < 0,05) differences existed between methods A and B compared to method C in Simmental and Holstein but not in Brown Swiss. We obtained best results in Simmental using method A (69%, n = 3384), while method C (61.4%, n = 763) was superior to methods A (57.6%. n = 698) and B (57.3%, n = 737) in Holstein. After considering various factors like preparation of extender, cost of materials and ambient working temperature, we concluded from our data that bull semen processing using TRIS-egg yolk extender and RT for packaging (method B) produced the best semen quality and field fertility. (C) 2002 Elsevier Science Inc. All rights reserved.