Does the histological subtype of high-grade central osteosarcoma influence the response to treatment with chemotherapy and does it affect overall survival? A study on 570 patients of two consecutive trials of the European Osteosarcoma Intergroup

Large randomised trials are mandatory when one wants to examine the effects of different aspects (such as the treatment modality) of a pathological condition on the overall outcome. This is especially true when studying a disease in which there is a multifactorial influence on progression and outcome such as osteosarcoma. Data on 570 patients with biopsy-proven primary central osteosarcoma of an extremity included in two consecutive studies of the European Osteosarcoma Intergroup (EOI) were analysed in order to evaluate if the histological subtype of the biopsy specimen correlated with the subtype of osteosarcoma represented in the resected specimen, if there was a relationship between the histological subtype and overall survival and if there was a relationship between the histological subtype and histological response to chemotherapy. High-grade osteosarcoma, as defined by established criteria, was subtyped as either conventional, chondroblastic, teleangiectatic, small cell, fibroblastic, osteoclast rich, anaplastic and sclerotic/osteoblastic well differentiated. A panel of experienced pathologists with a special interest in bone pathology was appointed to review the histological diagnosis and to assess the tumour response to chemotherapy on the resected specimen of each patient entered into the trials. Subtyping on the biopsy specimen proved to be highly representative for the subtype of the whole tumour. In 102 patients for which subtyping was performed on the biopsy and the resected specimens, there were only two discrepancies. Of the 568 patients for whom subtype was available, 404 (71%) were of the conventional type, 54 (10%) were chondroblastic, 53 (9%) had fibroblastic tumours and the remainder consisted of rare subtypes. A good response to preoperative chemotherapy was defined as 90% or more necrosis. The proportion of patients responding well to chemotherapy differed significantly between subtypes (Chi-square test statistics=11.44, P=0.01 on 3 degrees of freedom (d.f.)). In comparison with the conventional subtype, there was a higher proportion of good responders in the fibroblastic group and a lower proportion of good responders in the chondroblastic group. Good responders had a significantly better survival than patients who responded poorly to the pro-operative chemotherapy (logrank statistic=25.20, P<0.01 on 1 df). Survival did not differ significantly according to subtype (logrank statistic=2.72, P=0.44 on 3 df), although there was a suggestion that patients with chondroblastic tumours experienced a better long-term survival. This large set of prospectively-collected data provides important information on the relationship between pathological subtype, histological response and survival. Histological response has a known prognostic effect on survival, and we have shown that the rates of response differ by subtype. There is some evidence from this study that the specific histological subtypes, i.e. the chondroblastic subtype, experience better survival. However, despite this large multi-institutional study, we have insufficient numbers of non-conventional tumours to examine this unambiguously for these subsets. (C) 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.