Journal
JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY
Volume 53, Issue 1, Pages 140-149Publisher
WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/1365-2664.12552
Keywords
agriculture; agri-environment schemes; biodiversity indicator; common agricultural policy; empirical data; farming system; habitat; power analysis; sampling design; species trend
Categories
Funding
- EU 7th framework programme [KBBE 227161]
- EU BON project [308454]
- French Government through the A*MIDEX project [ANR-11-IDEX-0001-02]
- Lendulet program of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences
- Bolyai Fellowship
- MTA Postdoctoral fellowship
- Austrian Ministry for Science and Research
Ask authors/readers for more resources
To evaluate progress on political biodiversity objectives, biodiversity monitoring provides information on whether intended results are being achieved. Despite scientific proof that monitoring and evaluation increase the (cost) efficiency of policy measures, cost estimates for monitoring schemes are seldom available, hampering their inclusion in policy programme budgets. Empirical data collected from 12 case studies across Europe were used in a power analysis to estimate the number of farms that would need to be sampled per major farm type to detect changes in species richness over time for four taxa (vascular plants, earthworms, spiders and bees). A sampling design was developed to allocate spatially, across Europe, the farms that should be sampled. Cost estimates are provided for nine monitoring scenarios with differing robustness for detecting temporal changes in species numbers. These cost estimates are compared with the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) budget (2014-2020) to determine the budgetallocation required for the proposed farmland biodiversity monitoring. Results show that the bee indicator requires the highest number of farms to be sampled and the vascular plant indicator the lowest. The costs for the nine farmland biodiversity monitoring scenarios corresponded to 001%-074% of the total CAP budget and to 004%-248% of the CAP budget specifically allocated to environmental targets.Synthesis and applications. The results of the cost scenarios demonstrate that, based on the taxa and methods used in this study, a Europe-wide farmland biodiversity monitoring scheme would require a modest share of the Common Agricultural Policy budget. The monitoring scenarios are flexible and can be adapted or complemented with alternate data collection options (e.g. at national scale or voluntary efforts), data mobilization, data integration or modelling efforts. Editor's Choice
Authors
I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.
Reviews
Recommended
No Data Available