Mechanism for the paradoxical inhibition and stimulation of calcineurin by the immunosuppresive drug tacrolimus (FX506)

We examined the paradoxical inhibition and stimulation of calcineurin, the calcium-activated protein phosphatase, using the drug FK506 (tacrolimus) which acts as a complex together with its binding protein; the complex is designated here as FKC. We reproduced FKC inhibition with RIIp, a phosphorylated peptide substrate, and FKC stimulation with p-nitrophenylphosphate (pNPP) as substrate. The presence of RIIp, in the pNPP assay caused inhibition. Yet, under these conditions, FKC still stimulated pNPP dephosphorylation to the same extent. The effects of Mn2+ were strikingly different for the two substrates when calcineurin was measured under otherwise identical conditions: Mn2+ stimulated pNPP dephosphorylation several fold, but only stimulated RIIp dephosphorylation by about 50%. When Pi was used as product inhibitor, FKC stimulation, but not calmodulin stimulation, was attenuated. We conclude that FKC enhances substrate binding to the enzyme. This would lead to inhibition with RIIp, known to bind calcineurin tightly, but stimulation with pNPP, known to bind calcineurin weakly. The result not only resolves the paradox but also elucidates the mechanism of action for this class of immunosuppressive drugs. (C) 2003 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.