The effects of plant population size on the interactions between the endangered plant Scorzonera humilis, a specialised herbivore, and a phytopathogenic fungus

We studied the effects of population size on the interactions between Scorzonera humilis (Asteraceae), its specialised seed-feeding fly Heterostylodes macrurus (Anthomyidae) and its specific systemic smut fungus Ustilago scorzonerae (Ustilaginales). The number of seeds developing per plant (potential seed production) strongly increased with population size in S. humilis. However, because seed predation by the seed feeding fly H. macrurus and the negative impact of the pathogen U. scorzonerae also increased, realised seed production was not related to population size. The probability of occurrence of H. macrurus increased with the population size of its host plant and its abundance increased more than proportionally. This suggests that Allee effects reduce insect abundance in small populations of S. humilis. The probability of occurrence of the fungus U. scorzonerae also increased with plant population size. Within populations, large genets were more likely to be infected than small ones. The systemic pathogen U. scorzonerae reduces the effective population size of its host because all flowers of an infected individual are sterilised. Nevertheless, in most populations the impact of the fly on reproduction was stronger than that of the pathogen, because most genets were not infected. Both parasites were rarer than the host plant itself, supporting the trophic-level hypothesis of island biogeography. Our results suggest that habitat fragmentation may release plants from parasites and pathogens. These positive effects of isolation and small population size may mask negative effects of fragmentation on, for instance, the quantity and quality of pollination.