Pathomechanics in atraumatic shoulder instability - Scapular positioning correlates with humeral head centering

The objective was to analyze three-dimensional scapular positioning and glenohumeral centering of normal and atraumatic unstable shoulders. We hypothesized that changes of humeral head position correlate with alterations of scapular positioning. The shoulders of 28 healthy volunteers and 14 patients with atraumatic instability were examined in various arm positions using open magnetic resonance imaging. After segmentation and three-dimensional reconstruction, three-dimensional analyses of scapular positioning and humeral head position relative to the glenoid were done. The coefficient of correlation (r) between both parameters was determined using the correlation z test. The glenohumeral to scapulothoracic ratio in the scapular plane was increased in nine of 14 patients and decreased in three patients, whereas the scapular internal rotation in the transverse plane was increased in all unstable shoulders. The unstable shoulders also had malcentering (greater than two times the standard deviation in the healthy volunteers) of the humeral head in the direction of instability during various arm positions. In healthy and unstable shoulders, the correlation between scapular position and glenohumeral positioning was high during passive elevation (r = 0.60-0.87). The high correlation suggests that scapular positioning is relevant for humeral head decentering. Therefore, physiotherapeutic strategy should consider the malpositioning of the scapula and be adapted to the direction of instability.