Thermal habitat assessment of alternative flow scenarios in a tailwater fishery

Tailwaters below hydropower dams can create desirable coldwater trout fisheries; however, a flow regime ideal for hydropower often presents challenges for management of the fishery. The Smith River tailwater (Henry County, VA) offers a self-sustaining brown trout fishery managed for trophy trout (>= 406 mm), yet trophy-sized fish are rare. Slow growth and small size are likely caused by any one or a combination of thermal habitat, limited food resources, and/or physical habitat. To evaluate the potential for thermal habitat improvement, temperature changes resulting from alternative flows were assessed with a one-dimensional hydrodynamic model coupled with a water temperature model. Simulated temperatures from each flow scenario were assessed every 2 river kilometres over a 24 kilometre river section below the dam for occurrence of optimal growth temperatures, as well as compliance with Virginia Department of Environmental Quality hourly temperature change and daily maximum temperature standards. The occurrence of optimal growth temperatures increased up to 11.8% over existing conditions by releasing water in the morning, decreasing the duration of release, and not increasing baseflow. Incidences of hourly temperature changes greater than 2 degrees C were reduced from 4% to 0-1.2% by non-peaking releases, increasing baseflow, morning releases, and decreasing the duration of release. Maximum temperature occurrence (> 21 degrees C) decreased from 1.3% to 0-0.1% by releasing flows daily to prevent elevated temperatures on non-generation days, increasing baseflow, increasing duration of release, and releasing in the morning rather than evening. Despite conflicting adjustments to best improve all thermal criteria concurrently, a 7-day/week, morning, one hour release regime was determined to improve all criteria throughout the tailwater compared to existing conditions. Copyright (c) 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.