What makes an aquaporin a glycerol channel? A comparative study of AqpZ and GlpF

The recent availability of high-resolution structures of two structurally highly homologous, but functionally distinct aquaporins from the same species, namely Escherichia coli AqpZ, a pure water channel, and GIpF, a glycerol channel, presents a unique opportunity to understand the mechanism of substrate selectivity in these channels. Comparison of the free energy profile of glycerol conduction through AqpZ and GIpF reveals a much larger barrier in AqpZ (22.8 kcal/ mol) than in GlpF (7.3 kcal/mol). In either channel, the highest barrier is located at the selectivity filter. Analysis of substrate-protein interactions suggests that steric restriction of AqpZ is the main contribution to this large barrier. Another important difference is the presence of a deep energy well at the periplasmic vestibule of GIpF, which was not found in AqpZ. The latter difference can be attributed to the more pronounced structural asymmetry of GIpF, which may play a role in attracting glycerol.