Evaluation of reference tissue models for the analysis of [11C](R)-PK11195 studies

[C-11](R)-PK11195 is a marker of activated microglia, which can be used to measure inflammation in neurologic disorders. The purpose of the present study was to define the optimal reference tissue model based on a comparison with a validated plasma input model and using clinical studies and Monte Carlo simulations. Accuracy and reproducibility of reference tissue models were evaluated using Monte Carlo simulations. The effects of noise and variation in specific binding, nonspecific binding and blood volume were evaluated. Dynamic positron emission tomography scans were performed on 13 subjects, and radioactivity in arterial blood was monitored online. In addition, blood samples were taken to generate a metabolite corrected plasma input function. Both a (validated) two-tissue reversible compartment model with K-1/k(2) fixed to whole cortex and various reference tissue models were fitted to the data. Finally, a simplified reference tissue model (SRTM) corrected for nonspecific binding using plasma input data (SRTMpl-corr) was investigated. Correlations between reference tissue models (including SRTMpl-corr) and the plasma input model were calculated. Monte Carlo simulations indicated that low-specific binding results in decreased accuracy and reproducibility. In this respect, the SRTM and SRTMpl-corr performed relatively well. Varying blood volume had no effect on performance. In the clinical evaluation, SRTMpl-corr and SRTM had the highest correlations with the plasma input model (R-2 = 0.82 and 0.78, respectively). SRTMpl-corr is optimal when an arterial plasma input curve is available. Simplified reference tissue model is the best alternative when no plasma input is available.