Genotypic differences in grain yield of transplanted and direct-seeded rainfed lowland rice (Oryza sativa L.) in northeastern Thailand

We evaluated the genotypic differences in grain yield of 14 rice (Oryza sativa L.) genotypes with different phenology under four growing conditions: transplanting (TP) or direct-seeding (DS) in a toposequentially lower (with favorable water conditions) or upper (drought at around flowering stage) field at Ubon Ratchathani, northeastern Thailand. Thirteen of the genotypes - five early-maturing, four intermediate, and four late - had been bred for rainfed lowlands in northern and northeastern Thailand. IR24, a semi-dwarf, high-yielding, and early-maturing genotype bred for irrigated lowlands, was included for comparison. Genotypic differences in grain yield were significant in a combined analysis of all 4 growing conditions, and both high sink size (spikelet number per area) and high ripened grain percentage were associated with high yield. IR24 did not outyield the rainfed-lowland genotypes, and its yield was particularly low in DS, owing to poor shoot dry matter production and low spikelet number per panicle. In the lower field, the interaction between cultivation method and genotype was also significant. In the lower field, late maturity was more strongly related to high shoot dry weight at maturity in TP than in DS; some of the early- to intermediate-maturing genotypes in DS produced shoot dry weights at maturity that were comparable to those of the late-maturing genotypes. High shoot dry matter production and large spikelet number per particle were associated with high grain yield in DS genotypes in the lower field, whereas in TP genotypes with large numbers of panicles were required for high grain yield. Although the field location-genotype interaction and the field location-cultivation method-genotype interaction were not significant, regression analysis showed that late-maturing genotypes yielded less than earlier maturing genotypes, owing to the smaller ripened grain percentage resulting from late-season drought, in the upper field but not in the lower field. The presence of a trade-off between number of ripened grains and grain size in the lower field indicated the possibility of increasing the yield in rainfed-lowland genotypes by increasing assimilation capacity during grain filling. Phenology is important in the development of higher-yielding genotypes for different cultivation methods and different toposequential positions. (C) 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.