Critical evaluation of CFD codes for interfacial simulation of bubble-train flow in a narrow channel

Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes that are able to describe in detail the dynamic evolution of the deformable interface in gas-liquid or liquid-liquid flows may be a valuable tool to explore the potential of multi-fluid flow in narrow channels for process intensification. In the present paper, a computational exercise for co-current bubble-train flow in a square vertical mini-channel is performed to investigate the performance of well-known CFD codes for this type of flows. The computations are based on the volume-of-fluid method (VOF) where the transport equation for the liquid volumetric fraction is solved either by the methods involving a geometrical reconstruction of the interface or by the methods that use higher-order difference schemes instead. The codes contributing to the present code-to-code comparison are an in-house code and the commercial CFD packages CFX, FLUENT and STAR-CD. Results are presented for two basic cases. In the first one, the flow is driven by buoyancy only, while in the second case the flow is additionally forced by an external pressure gradient. The results of the code-to-code comparison show that only the VOF method with interface reconstruction leads to physically sound and consistent results, whereas the use of difference schemes for the volume fraction equation shows some deficiencies. Copyright (C) 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.