Blend-then-Index or Index-then-Blend: A Theoretical Analysis for Generating High-resolution NDVI Time Series by STARFM

There are two strategies for generating high-resolution vegetation index time series using spatiotemporal data blending methods, named as Blend-then-Index (BI) and Index-then-Blend (IB), according to the order of vegetation index calculation and data blending. This study aims to determine which strategy can obtain better results for generating a high-resolution normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) time series using the spatial and temporal adaptive reflectance fusion model (STARFM). The theoretical error analysis suggests that the more accurate strategy depends on the vegetation growth stages: BI has a smaller error than IB when the NDVI values at the prediction date are higher than the input NDVI values and vice versa. Simulated experiments using Landsat images were conducted to verify the theoretical analysis. This study provides guidelines for producing better high-resolution vegetation index time series using STARFM.