Stress-Induced, Highly Efficient, Donor Cell-Dependent Cell-to-Cell Natural Transformation in Bacillus subtilis

Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is a driving force for bacterial evolution that occurs via conjugation, transduction, and transformation. Whereas conjugation and transduction depend on nonbacterial vehicles, transformation is considered a naturally occurring process in which naked DNA molecules are taken up by a competent recipient cell. Here, we report that HGT occurred between two Bacillus subtilis strains cocultured on a minimum medium agar plate for 10 h. This process was almost completely resistant to DNase treatment and appeared to require close proximity between cells. The deletion of comK in the recipient completely abolished gene transfer, indicating that the process involved transformation. This process was also highly efficient, reaching 1.75 x 10(6) transformants/mu g DNA compared to 5.3 x 10(3) and 1.86 x 10(5) transformants/mu g DNA for DNA-to-cell transformation by the same agar method and the standard two-step procedure, respectively. Interestingly, when three distantly localized chromosomal markers were selected simultaneously, the efficiency of cell-to-cell transformation still reached 6.26 x 10(4) transformants/mu g DNA, whereas no transformants were obtained when free DNA was used as the donor. Stresses, such as starvation and exposure to antibiotics, further enhanced transformation efficiency by affecting the donor cells, suggesting that stress served as an important signal for promoting this type of HGT. Taken together, our results defined a bona fide process of cell-to-cell natural transformation (CTCNT) in B. subtilis and related species. This finding reveals the previously unrecognized role of donor cells in bacterial natural transformation and improves our understanding of how HGT drives bacterial evolution at a mechanistic level. IMPORTANCE Because DNA is easily prepared, studies of bacterial natural genetic transformation traditionally focus on recipient cells. However, such laboratory artifacts cannot explain how this process occurs in nature. In most cases, competence is only transient and involves approximately 20 to 50 genes, and it is unreasonable for bacteria to spend so many genetic resources on unpredictable and uncertain environmental DNA. Here, we characterized a donor cell-dependent CTCNT process in B. subtilis and related species that was almost completely resistant to DNase treatment and was more efficient than classical natural transformation using naked DNA as a donor, i.e., DNA-to-cell transformation, suggesting that DNA donor cells were also important in the transformation process in natural environments.