Insulin-sensitive and insulin-resistant obese and non-obese phenotypes: role in prediction of incident pre-diabetes in a longitudinal biracial cohort

Objective We measured insulin sensitivity with euglycemic clamp (Si-clamp) in initially normoglycemic African Americans (AA) and European Americans (EA), to probe the existence of subphenotypes of obesity and leanness, and their impact on incident dysglycemia during longitudinal follow-up. Research design and methods 320 healthy subjects (176 AA, 144 EA; mean age 44.2 +/- 10.6 years) underwent baseline assessments, including Si-clamp and homeostasis model of insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) and were stratified into: insulin-resistant obese (IRO) (body mass index (BMI) >= 30 kg/m(2), Si-clamp <0.1, HOMA-IR >= 2.5); insulin-sensitive obesity (ISO) (BMI >= 30 kg/m(2), Si-clamp >= 0.1, HOMA-IR <2.5); insulin-resistant non-obese (IRN) (BMI <28 kg/m(2), Si-clamp <0.1, HOMA-IR >= 2.5); insulin-sensitive non-obese (ISN) (BMI <28 kg/m(2), Si-clamp >= 0.1, HOMA-IR <2.5). Outcome measures were cardiometabolic risks and incident pre-diabetes/type 2 diabetes (T2D) during 5.5 years. Results Compared with IRO, subjects with ISO had lower abdominal fat, triglycerides and high-sensitivity C reactive protein and higher adiponectin (p=0.015 to <0.0001). IRN subjects had higher cardiometabolic risk markers than ISN (p=0.03 to <0.0001). During 5.5-year follow-up, incident pre-diabetes/T2D was lower in ISO (31.3% vs 48.7%) among obese subjects and higher in IRN (47.1% vs. 26.0%) among non-obese subjects (p=0.0024). Kaplan-Meier analysis showed significantly different pre-diabetes/T2D survival probabilities across insulin sensitivity/adiposity phenotypes (p=0.0001). Conclusions Insulin sensitivity predicts similar to 40% decrease in the relative risk of incident pre-diabetes/T2D among obese persons, whereas insulin resistance predicts similar to 80% increased risk among non-obese persons. This is the first documentation of healthy and unhealthy phenotypes of obesity and leanness in a prospective biracial cohort, using rigorous measurement of insulin sensitivity.