An NMR Crystallographic Investigation of the Relationships between the Crystal Structure and 29Si Isotropic Chemical Shift in Silica Zeolites

NMR crystallography has recently been applied to great effect for silica zeolites. Here we investigate whether it is possible to extend the structural information available from routine NMR spectra via a simple structure-spectrum relationship. Unlike previous empirically derived relationships that have compared experimental crystal structures for (often disordered) silicates with experimental NMR spectra, where the structure may not be an accurate representation of the material studied experimentally, we use NMR parameters calculated by density functional theory (DFT) for both model Si(OSi(OH)(3))(4) clusters and also extended zeolitic SiO2 frameworks, for which the input structure corresponding to the NMR parameters is known exactly. We arrive at a structure spectrum relationship dependent on the mean Si-O bond length, mean Si-O-Si bond angle, and the standard deviations of both parameters, which can predict to within 1.3 ppm the Si-29 isotropic magnetic shielding that should be obtained from a DFT calculation. While this semiempirical relationship will never supersede DFT where this is possible, it does open up the possibility of a rapid estimation of the outcome of a DFT calculation where the actual calculation would be prohibitively costly or otherwise challenging. We also investigate the structural optimization of SiO2 zeolites using DFT, demonstrating that the mean Si-O bond lengths all tend to 1.62 angstrom and the distortion index tends to <2.0 degrees, suggesting that these metrics may be suitable for rapid validation of whether a given crystal structure represents a realistic local geometry around Si, or merely a bulk average with contributions from several different local geometries.