Is Domain Knowledge Necessary for Machine Learning Materials Properties?

New featurization schemes for describing materials as composition vectors in order to predict their properties using machine learning are common in the field of Materials Informatics. However, little is known about the comparative efficacy of these methods. This work sets out to make clear which featurization methods should be used across various circumstances. Our findings include, surprisingly, that simple fractional and random-noise representations of elements can be as effective as traditional and new descriptors when using large amounts of data. However, in the absence of large datasets or for data that is not fully representative, we show that the integration of domain knowledge offers advantages in predictive ability. [GRAPHICS] .