Determining the Safety Threshold for the Passage of a Ureteral Access Sheath in Clinical Practice Using a Purpose-Built Force Sensor

Purpose: Ureteral injury is a frequent complication of ureteral access sheath deployment. We sought to define the safe threshold of force for the passage of a ureteral access sheath using a novel ureteral access sheath force sensor. Materials and Methods: Ureteral access sheath-force sensor measurements were recorded in 210 renal units. A 16Fr ureteral access sheath was deployed initially based on a prior porcine study. If 6 N was reached, the surgeon was advised to downsize the 16Fr ureteral access sheath. In each case, a post-ureteroscopic lesion scale was recorded. Regression models were used to estimate the impact of adjusted variables on post-ureteroscopic lesion scale grade, 16Fr ureteral access sheath deployment, and peak force. Results: A 16Fr ureteral access sheath was deployed in 127 (61%) renal units with a mean peak force of 5.7 N. Two high-grade ureteral injuries occurred; in both cases >6 N of force was recorded. Post-ureteroscopic lesion scale grade correlated directly with peak insertion force (p <0.01). Bacteriuria within 60 days of the procedure (OR 2.009, p=0.034), combination of preoperative stent plus oral tamsulosin (OR 2.998, p=0.045), and prior ipsilateral stone surgery (OR 2.13, p=0.01) were independent predictors of successful 16Fr ureteral access sheath deployment. Among patients with neither prior ipsilateral stone surgery nor preoperative stent, preoperative tamsulosin facilitated passage of a 16Fr ureteral access sheath (OR 2.750, p=0.034). Conclusions: Ureteral access sheath associated ureteral injury can be averted by limiting the insertion force to <= 6 N. Prior stone surgery, preoperative indwelling ureteral stent plus oral tamsulosin, and recently treated bacteriuria favored passage of a 16Fr ureteral access sheath. In the naive, unstented patient, preoperative tamsulosin favored deployment of a 16Fr ureteral access sheath.

Automated summary

The study found that limiting the insertion force of a ureteral access sheath to <= 6 N can prevent ureteral injury. Prior medical history, presence of stents, and medication treatment can influence the deployment of a 16Fr ureteral access sheath.