An Evaluation Framework for Second-Life EV/PHEV Battery Application in Power Systems

Energy storage is essential for balancing the generation and load in power systems. Building a battery energy storage system (BESS) with retired battery packs from electric vehicles (EVs) or plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs) is one possible way to subsidize the price of EV/PHEV batteries, and at the same time mitigating forecast error introduced by load and renewable energy sources in power systems. This paper proposes a detailed framework to evaluate end-of-life (EOL) EV/PHEV batteries in BESS application. The framework consists of three parts. A generalized model for battery degradation is first introduced. It is followed by modeling the battery retirement process in its first life. Two vehicle types-EV and PHEV-as well as two retirement modes-nominal and realistic modes-are considered. Finally, the application of the second-life BESS in power systems is modeled in a detailed economic dispatch (ED) problem. This is how second-life BESS's performance translates into cost savings on power generation. An optimization problem is formulated to maximize total cost savings in power generation over the battery's second life. This is done by striking a balance between short-term benefit (daily cost savings) and long-term benefit (cost savings through service years). Numerical results validate the effectiveness of the proposed framework/models. They show that battery usage and retirement criterion in its first life directly affect the performance in its second life application. In our case study, EV battery packs possess larger EOL energy capacities and consequently generate more cost savings in the second life. However, the BESS built from retired PHEV batteries has higher cost savings per MWh. It is because, with the proposed degradation model, battery health is better preserved in PHEV applications. Compared to nominal retirement mode, realistic retirement mode results in extra cost savings due to the reduced first-life service years.

Automated summary

Utilizing retired electric vehicle and plug-in hybrid electric vehicle batteries to build a battery energy storage system can subsidize the price of EV/PHEV batteries and mitigate forecast errors in power systems. This paper proposes a detailed framework to evaluate the application of end-of-life EV/PHEV batteries in BESS, showing that battery usage and retirement criteria in the first life directly impact performance in the second life application. In a case study, EV battery packs have larger EOL energy capacities, leading to more cost savings in the second life, while BESS built from retired PHEV batteries show higher cost savings per MWh due to better battery health preservation.